A North Texas school donated land to a Christian faculty. State and federal legal guidelines prohibit such presents, specialists say

This text is co-published with ProPublica, a nonprofit newsroom that investigates abuses of energy. Join ProPublica’s Large Story publication to obtain tales like this one in your inbox as quickly as they’re printed. Additionally, join The Temporary, our each day publication that retains readers on top of things on essentially the most important Texas information.

In 2004, a public junior school in North Texas deserted plans to lease a few of its land to a spiritual group for $1 month after the state legal professional basic warned that the hassle may violate the legislation.

Practically 20 years later, the school went additional. After publicly posting solely that Weatherford Faculty’s board would meet to debate property, members emerged from behind closed doorways in November 2022 and voted unanimously to offer a 38-acre property to Neighborhood Christian Faculty. The property was valued at greater than $2 million, in response to the county’s appraisal district.

“Faith and patience is the path,” Dan Curlee, then the school’s legal professional, wrote in an e mail after the vote to Doug Jefferson, the administrator of the non-public non secular faculty.

Jefferson, who had requested the school to donate its workforce growth heart in Mineral Wells, about 50 miles west of Fort Price, replied: “Praise God. He has walked with me every step of the way on this miracle for our school. So appreciate you,” in response to data obtained by ProPublica and The Texas Tribune.

About two years later, the property sits empty as Neighborhood Christian Faculty raises the funds wanted to make repairs that Jefferson estimates will value $1.2 million. The donation additionally raises questions on authorities oversight at a time when state and native officers are more and more blurring the strains between church and state, specialists mentioned.

Authorized specialists say the donation seems to have violated a number of state and federal legal guidelines, together with a provision within the Texas Structure that prohibits political subdivisions, together with public junior schools, from granting something of worth to assist a person, affiliation or company with out return profit. In addition they pointed to a different provision in state legislation that prohibits public junior schools from conveying, promoting or exchanging their land for lower than honest market worth until the land goes to an abutting property proprietor.

In 2004, then-state Lawyer Basic Greg Abbott, now the governor, cited that provision when Weatherford Faculty had deliberate to lease half an acre of land to the Wesley Basis, a United Methodist campus ministry that deliberate to construct a scholar heart with a nondenominational chapel and church administrative workplaces. Abbott’s opinion mentioned Texas legislation required the school to cost honest market worth when promoting or leasing land and to take care of management over the property, which the general public faculty system had not completed.

Retired Baylor College legislation professor Ron Beal mentioned the identical tenets apply to the newer transaction. Had the school merely seemed again on Abbott’s 2004 opinion, it could have recognized higher, he mentioned. “The junior college is absolutely prohibited from doing what they did,” he mentioned. “It was a pure gratuitous transfer of public monies to solely benefit private persons at the expense of state taxpayers.”

Texas supplies little oversight in such circumstances. Neighborhood school land transactions should not beneath the purview of the Texas Greater Schooling Coordinating Board, which oversees public junior schools, in response to an company spokesperson. The spokesperson mentioned complaints about such transactions will be filed with the legal professional basic, who can select whether or not to analyze. The Texas legal professional basic’s workplace, which didn’t reply to requests for remark, didn’t obtain complaints associated to the donation, in response to data obtained by ProPublica and the Tribune.

Faculty board members who voted in favor of the donation both didn’t reply to requests for remark or declined to talk with the information organizations.

The donation typically went beneath the radar even within the small, rural neighborhood. The native paper lined a ribbon-cutting ceremony however didn’t deal with the legality of the donation. John Kuhn, who served as superintendent for the Mineral Wells Impartial Faculty District on the time, mentioned he had no concept the school was donating the land. Had Kuhn recognized, he mentioned he would have requested that his district be thought of. It’s operating out of house in its elementary faculties and may need even contemplated shopping for the property, Kuhn mentioned.

Other than the authorized questions, the donation raises issues in a state that more and more blurs the road between church and state, mentioned College of Houston political scientist Brandon Rottinghaus. He pointed to examples together with a brand new legislation that enables faculties to rent unlicensed chaplains to work in psychological well being roles, Abbott’s arduous push for a college voucher-like program that might permit taxpayer funding to help non-public and non secular schooling, and the State Board of Schooling’s consideration of a measure that might require faculties to show the Bible.

“Over time, you’ve had so many of these issues that have battered the guardrails to the point now where it’s hard to have the guardrails be the divider of church and state as designed in some of these laws,” Rottinghaus mentioned.

Curlee, the school’s legal professional who has since retired, mentioned the potential legal responsibility of proudly owning the getting old property outweighed its usefulness and that the school had already began transferring courses to different buildings previous to the donation. He and the school’s present legal professional, Jay Rutherford, keep the donation didn’t violate any legal guidelines. Neither defined their reasoning or responded to questions on what authorized specialists advised ProPublica and the Tribune.

These specialists additionally mentioned the donation seems to violate the U.S. Structure as a result of, by Curlee’s personal acknowledgment, the school by no means listed the property on the market and didn’t supply to donate it to another organizations.

“If there’s evidence here that the college was not neutral, and that it was favoring this Christian school and left everyone else out of the process, that would violate the principle of Carson v. Makin,” mentioned Steven Collis, a legislation professor and director of the Legislation and Faith Clinic on the College of Texas at Austin, referring to a case wherein the Supreme Court docket dominated that Maine’s faculty voucher program couldn’t exclude non secular faculties.

Jefferson, the administrator of Neighborhood Christian Faculty, mentioned he didn’t consider the donation violated any legal guidelines and that God gave him the property as a reward for taking good care of it prior to now. The non-public Christian faculty would at instances use the property for gratis for one-act play competitions. When it did so, Jefferson mentioned he cleaned, paid for utilities and supplied legal responsibility insurance coverage.

“And I did that because I believe God said that building belongs to us. I believed for years and years that was going to happen and then it did,” he mentioned.

Disclosure: Baylor College, the College of Texas at Austin and the College of Houston have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full checklist of them right here.

TribFest Keynotes Introduced! Be there when Michigan Gov. Gretchen Whitmer and Virginia Gov. Glenn Youngkin take the keynote stage at The Texas Tribune Competition! Whitmer will speak with Texas Tribune co-founder Evan Smith about her memoir, her key victories in Michigan and the significance of each vote. Youngkin and Smith will shut out TribFest with a dialog about his file, the state of his get together and a conservative coverage agenda for America. Discover the total program of 300+ audio system and 100+ occasions. Get tickets immediately.