In Texas, non-public companies money in on property tax late charges, piling debt onto struggling householders

Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s day by day e-newsletter that retains readers in control on essentially the most important Texas information.

---

GARDENDALE — In October, Sarah Rojo discovered herself drowning in property tax debt.

She owed $23,778 on the “dream home” she constructed outdoors Odessa together with her husband, Raul, earlier than he died out of the blue in 2019.

She owed $5,727 on the house with the limestone trim she acquired from her father, who handed in 2008. And he or she owed $22,742 on her grandmother’s pink home 5 blocks away, on the opposite facet of Zavala Elementary, that she inherited two years earlier than.

For being late on her payments, she owed $10,142 in penalties and curiosity.

And eventually, she owed one other $7,977 to the non-public legislation agency Ector County employed to gather the debt from her.

Her husband’s loss of life, of a stroke at 53, meant the tip of their mom-and-pop oilfield electrician enterprise the place he labored the patch and he or she managed the books. Rojo saved up with the taxes on their house for 2 years by drawing down her financial savings and dealing at Goodwill and as a secretary at her church. However as soon as the property turned delinquent, with the opposite properties already late, the charges piled up shortly.

“It had been weighing on me very hard,” Rojo mentioned. “I wanted to pay it myself, but it was not possible.”

Texas has the seventh-highest property taxes within the nation, in response to the Tax Basis, an unwelcome distinction state officers have for years tried to shed as they’ve repeatedly promised to ease the burden on struggling householders like Rojo. But when those self same Texans fall behind on these taxes, The Texas Tribune discovered that the state employs one of the crucial punitive price buildings in America, which permits non-public legislation companies employed to gather the money owed to cost an extra 20% on high of present base taxes, penalties and curiosity.

No different state outsources delinquent tax assortment to the diploma it occurs in Texas, the place hundreds of entities accumulating native college, county and municipal property taxes achieve this beneath a system the Legislature created in 1979.

The cottage business that grew in response is exclusive to the state — and profitable. Legislation companies accumulating delinquent taxes within the 100 most populous Texas counties earned at the very least $184 million in income in 2023 — which quantities to billions of {dollars} over the course of the greater than 4 a long time Texas has allowed this follow.

The Tribune calculated the gathering charges for a yr by acquiring contracts and cost experiences by way of a whole bunch of public information requests to county tax workplaces, appraisal districts, cities and college districts. That sum, which is an undercount as a result of among the smaller counties in that group didn’t present their figures, is bigger than the annual finances of Beaumont.

Nearly all of the charges went to simply three Texas companies: at the very least $128 million to Linebarger Goggan Blair and Sampson, adopted by at the very least $28 million to Perdue Brandon Fielder Collins and Mott and at the very least $18 million to McCreary Veselka Bragg and Allen.

State Sen. Judith Zaffirini, D-Laredo, mentioned the Tribune’s findings increase considerations concerning the monetary burden positioned on Texans, “many of whom are already struggling to pay their property taxes.” She mentioned lawmakers ought to contemplate reforms, together with reducing the charges legislation companies can cost.

“The fees imposed by third-party collection firms can compound the financial challenges faced by delinquent taxpayers,” Zaffirini, a member of the Senate Finance Committee, mentioned in an e-mail. “This system should balance the need for efficient tax collection with fairness and compassion, ensuring that Texans are not penalized excessively for falling behind on their payments.”

The urge for food for reform amongst Republicans, who management each lever of state authorities, is unclear. Gov. Greg Abbott, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick and Home Speaker Dustin Burrows — three of the loudest advocates for property tax aid this legislative session — didn’t reply to interview requests.

A Home committee chaired by Burrows in 2020 examined the state’s system of permitting outsourced delinquent tax assortment and endorsed it as successful.

Outsourcing is near-universal amongst taxing entities. However in 2023, Harris County — essentially the most populous in Texas — started transitioning to in-house delinquent assortment. Its leaders made that call after discovering that greater than two-thirds of overdue householders lived in poorer, majority Black and Hispanic precincts.

Travis County has by no means outsourced, concluding that doing so would topic taxpayers to pointless further charges with no additional benefit for the federal government.

“It behooves me to never lose sight of the fact that there are people who are living on the edge,” mentioned Travis County Tax Assessor-Collector Celia Israel, including that her workplace maintains a group fee close to 100%.

Outsourcing tax assortment is a beautiful choice to native governments as a result of it’s free for them, because the legislation companies draw income straight from delinquent taxpayers. County tax collectors mentioned the companies have experience and know-how — like software program and name facilities — that they lack in their very own workplaces.

Layne Younger, chief appraiser for the Ector County Appraisal District, which handles tax assortment there, acknowledged the additional 20% charged to the county’s delinquent taxpayers will be onerous. He mentioned one of the best ways to keep away from it’s to pay on time.

“We’re following what the tax code currently regulates us to do; if the legislators want to change something, we’ll follow that as well,” Younger mentioned.

Republican Rep. Brooks Landgraf, who represents Ector County, the place Rojo lives, declined to remark. Landgraf was one of many 66 Home co-sponsors on a precedence invoice in 2023 to decrease property taxes.

Some tax business professionals are skeptical outsourcing is value the additional price to delinquent taxpayers.

Artwork Martinez de Vara, a Bexar County tax lawyer who served as chief of workers to former Republican state Sen. Konni Burton from 2014 to 2015, mentioned most tax circumstances are a comparatively easy space of legislation and primarily based on public information native governments already possess. He mentioned taxing entities might seemingly present the identical service at a a lot decrease price than the charges the Tribune discovered.

“My politics, I tend to prefer outsourcing items, usually because of efficiencies,” Martinez mentioned. “But I think with that amount of revenue coming in, it’s definitely worth looking at a governmental solution to that.”

Property taxes are the principle funding sources for Texas counties, cities and college districts. For a lot of the twentieth century, elected county tax collectors did a poor job, hobbled by antiquated know-how, artificially low value determinations and accusations of selective enforcement, in response to legislative testimony and the state comptroller. Robert Mott, a former companion at Perdue Brandon, informed a Home committee in 2020 that when he started his profession on the comptroller’s workplace in 1977, many entities had been accumulating lower than 90% of their current-year taxes.

The Legislature in 1979 formalized a follow of outsourcing this work to personal legislation companies that some taxing entities had been already doing. Two years later, lawmakers allowed the companies to gather a price straight from delinquent taxpayers.

The distinction in method is as a lot ethical and political as it’s financial: Ought to the price of delinquent assortment be unfold out over all taxpayers, or ought to that burden, nonetheless giant, be borne solely by the small group who fall behind?

Avoiding further prices for the “good taxpayer” who pays on time, is a significant argument for the companies, who say they’re offering an environment friendly service that taxing entities would in any other case have to rent workers to do.

Linebarger Goggan Blair & Sampson, the dominant participant within the business, has collected court docket charges, overdue toll costs and different money owed on behalf of native governments since 1976. However about 60% of its enterprise in Texas comes from accumulating delinquent taxes for greater than 2,400 entities, Edward Lopez, Jr., a companion on the agency’s Dallas workplace, mentioned in an interview.

Outsourcing achieved the Legislature’s aim of bettering collections; Lopez mentioned the present assortment charges within the state’s largest counties exceed 98%.

The agency makes use of plenty of techniques to encourage debtors to pay, together with cellphone calls, letters and, for some shoppers, in-person visits. Its instruments embrace proprietary software program, which Linebarger touts because the business’s finest, that may monitor down evasive debtors. Lopez mentioned the aim is to safe cost in full or commit the debtor to a month-to-month installment plan. If these efforts fail, the agency can file a lawsuit towards the debtor to win a judgment for the owed taxes and charges. And if the debtor nonetheless fails to pay, the agency can organize for the property to be bought at a tax sale.

Lopez mentioned 96% of the accounts the agency collects on it does so with out taking debtors to court docket. However he described lawsuits as an important software, the place circumstances will be way more advanced than critics contend — particularly when a enterprise or a chapter is concerned. He recounted a compromise he negotiated between Dallas County and the Roman Catholic Diocese of Dallas the place the church agreed to pay taxes on five-sevenths of a parking storage — the times of the week it wasn’t utilizing the construction for spiritual functions.

Lopez mentioned the 20% most price is cheap. He declined to supply the agency’s revenue margin for delinquent tax assortment however mentioned the Tribune’s income discovering have to be positioned within the context of the numerous prices Linebarger incurs to carry out the work. Up to now yr, he mentioned the agency despatched 2.1 million letters, made 712,000 cellphone calls and posted 2,700 properties for tax gross sales.

“We only get paid if we collect it. We don’t get paid by churning in hours,” Lopez mentioned. “I have cases that I’ve worked on for 20 years … that we’ve never been paid on, and that has happened quite a lot.”

Michael Berlanga, a Licensed Public Accountant, actual property dealer and property tax advisor in San Antonio, mentioned the legislation companies overstate the complexity of delinquent tax assortment. Whereas the companies had an enormous technological benefit 40 years in the past, when few tax workplaces had computer systems, monetary software program and information storage at the moment are low-cost and broadly out there.

“Linebarger, over decades, has convinced the taxing authorities ‘we’re more efficient than y’all are,’” Berlanga mentioned. “When’s the last time… the performance of Linebarger was audited against the supposition that ‘We would have collected that money anyway?’”

A Perdue Brandon consultant mentioned the explanation 252 of the state’s 254 counties outsource delinquent tax assortment is as a result of it’s an environment friendly public-private partnership. The income generated by the attorneys charges, the agency mentioned, is proof of this and represents their success in accumulating way more in taxes that return to authorities coffers “at no cost to the entities or the taxpayers who timely paid their taxes that were used to provide necessary services for their communities.”

McCreary Veselka Bragg & Allen didn’t reply to interview requests.

The taxing entities that do in-house assortment say they’re defending taxpayers, too — those who’re most at-risk of dropping their properties.

Delinquent taxpayers already face steep charges mandated by state legislation. As soon as a property turns into delinquent on Feb. 1, a 6% penalty applies, growing 1% per 30 days as much as 12%. Curiosity accrues at 1% month-to-month till the tax is paid.

Which means that after six months, an unpaid $5,000 tax invoice would balloon by 18% to $5,900. With a 20% lawyer price, which will be charged starting July 1, it will leap to $7,080.

Israel, the Travis County tax assessor, mentioned native governments have to steadiness the necessity to accumulate the taxes that fund providers with a compassion for households which can be typically in disaster.

Travis County studied whether or not to outsource in 2005, concluding that doing so wouldn’t enhance assortment charges however would cost debtors pointless charges The tax workplace, which collects for 150 taxing entities within the county, estimates the mannequin saves delinquent taxpayers greater than $10 million yearly.

There are different outliers. Aldine ISD, a district of 57,000 college students that straddles working-class neighborhoods in north Houston, moved to in-house assortment within the Eighties. The district collected delinquent taxes extra shortly whereas sparing debtors the additional charges merely for paying late, mentioned Annette Ramirez, who labored as a tax lawyer there for 23 years.

“These taxpayers … we’re accountable to them. We’re really just helping them get through this,” Ramirez mentioned. “Nobody wants to be in the position that they’re in.”

The district would recoup prices from debtors solely once they needed to file a lawsuit, and people charges paid for the entire tax workplace, she mentioned.

Ramirez final yr was elected Harris County tax assessor-collector, the place she is overseeing the transition of the state’s largest county to the in-house mannequin. The county lawyer estimated the change saved debtors $8.8 million in charges the primary yr, whereas assortment charges remained the identical.

Jonathan Fombonne, deputy county lawyer, estimated that in-house delinquent tax assortment prices the county $10 million yearly. Unfold out over the county’s 4.8 million residents, he mentioned that’s the equal of some {dollars} on the typical home-owner’s tax invoice.

The Legislature has repeatedly highlighted property tax aid throughout the previous 4 classes. Final session, Abbott touted passing the most important property tax minimize in Texas historical past, and in February he listed property tax aid as his high legislative precedence.

“Taxpayers in the state of Texas have been burdened with an oppressive property tax system that takes too much money out of their pockets,” the governor mentioned at a 2019 invoice signing.

Lawmakers have constantly supported the outsourcing mannequin — which digs additional into the pockets of house owners who change into delinquent. The unique outsourcing statutes capped the utmost assortment price at 15% however lawmakers raised it to twenty% in 2001 on the request of the legislation companies. Of the 88 outsourcing contracts obtained by the Tribune, 70% allow the companies to gather the utmost price.

The Texas Home Methods and Means Committee in 2020 reviewed the delinquent assortment system, holding a listening to that included testimony from the highest three companies and native tax collectors.

Mott, the previous companion at Perdue Brandon, testified that outsourcing has been the “biggest success probably in privatization in Texas” due to how the legislation companies improved assortment charges.

“The system ain’t broke, so please don’t try to fix it,” Matthew Tepper, the president of MVBA, urged the committee.

The committee heard no testimony from anybody representing delinquent taxpayers, the group accountable for paying the brand new charges outsourcing created. Its report famous taxing entities aren’t required to rent third-party collectors, and really useful no modifications to the outsourcing system.

The legislation companies are well-positioned to guard their pursuits contained in the Capitol. The highest three have 26 registered lobbyists for the present legislative session, whereas Linebarger leads with $440,000 in marketing campaign contributions to legislators and statewide elected officers since 2023.

The trouble extends domestically. In Dallas County, Linebarger and its present and former companions are the most important political contributor to Tax Assessor-Collector John Ames, accounting for 41% of his contributions the previous two years. The agency earned $21.1 million in 2023 in Dallas County, its most useful relationship with any county tax workplace.

Ames mentioned the contributions would don’t have any affect on his opinion if county leaders sought his enter on whether or not to resume Linebarger’s contract. He praised the agency’s professionalism and repair.

Throughout the state, lower than 5% of property house owners fail to pay their taxes on time annually. Seven delinquent house and enterprise house owners who spoke with the Tribune mentioned they had been hardworking Texans stretched skinny even earlier than dealing with the tough charges. They every described a latest monetary hardship: a job loss, a loss of life within the household or a season the place gross sales plummeted.

In Montgomery County, north of Houston, a tan ranch home with a leaking roof close to the middle of Patton Village has been delinquent a lot of the previous 20 years. Roy Bedgood Jr. owned the house in 2000 when most cancers killed him at 46 and the property went to his three youngsters, his son Chris mentioned. Chris’ brother deliberate to maneuver in (he did) and pay the taxes (he didn’t), making a cycle of delinquency the household has discovered troublesome to interrupt.

Via February, the excellent invoice for the property was $28,000, together with $4,700 in charges to Linebarger and Perdue Brandon. Chris Bedgood, a storage door technician like his father, and his spouse raised his brother’s youngsters and likewise residing with their grownup son, who has particular wants. He’s contemplating promoting different property he owns to repay the debt however needs the attorneys charges had not inflated it.

“If the price was lower, I would have already put it on a payment plan and paid it, but it jumped so high so quick,” Bedgood mentioned. “I’m 50 and I really don’t have a retirement plan, and I’ve worked every day of my life. And I don’t do drugs or drink.”

Jennie Treese desires to promote her mom’s brick house on a quiet cul-de-sac in The Woodlands to repay the $31,000 tax invoice — together with $5,200 in lawyer charges — and put the remainder of the proceeds in the direction of the way forward for her household.

Her mom Mary Treese taught particular schooling in Conroe ISD for a few years till failing eyesight compelled her to retire. She died in February 2024 with no will, complicating issues for Jennie, her solely youngster.

Jennie remains to be ready to be declared the house’s proprietor by a choose, nonetheless. And in the meantime, one other yr of taxes and lawyer charges have been added to the invoice. Treese mentioned she doesn’t perceive why charges can’t be halted. The companies don’t have to chase her down, she causes, noting she has known as the tax workplace to advise workers of her scenario.

“We have every intention of paying the taxes,” Treese mentioned. “We’ve done all the things responsibly that we need to do.”

Treese mentioned delinquent taxpayers are sometimes unfairly vilified for being irresponsible. After a lifetime of public service, she mentioned her mom, blind in her remaining years, misplaced monitor of her taxes.

“She maintained as much independence as she could, and this is one of the areas in which that failed,” Treese mentioned. “But she wasn’t a villain. She wasn’t a drain on society.”

Bedgood’s state consultant, Republican Janis Holt, mentioned she sees no drawback with taxing entities with the ability to outsource for an additional price. She mentioned she can be open to reviewing laws that will make it simpler for taxing entities to maneuver assortment in-house. Republican Rep. Steve Toth, who represents Treese, declined to remark.

Montgomery County Tax Assessor-Collector Tammy McRae was unavailable for an interview. County Lawyer B.D. Griffin, who responded on her behalf, mentioned McRae and her workers attempt to assist taxpayers keep away from delinquency or decrease its results by internet hosting workshops and distributing pamphlets about varied cost choices, together with prepayment, partial funds and deferrals.

In Odessa, Sarah Rojo saved her debt secret from her son Ryan, a Catholic priest in San Angelo, understanding he’d wish to assist regardless of a modest earnings. However after her different son, Raul Jr., died in November after again surgical procedure, she got here clear. Collectively, Ryan and Sarah put collectively a plan to get her monetary life again on monitor.

They are going to hire out her mom and grandmother’s former properties to safe an earnings stream. They paid off among the taxes and plan to enter right into a three-year cost plan with Linebarger for the remaining steadiness. The month-to-month funds can be round $600 — about $120 increased than if there have been no authorized charges — which Sarah acknowledges would require an austere life-style targeted on wants somewhat than desires. She nonetheless works on the church and can take a second job if she has to; a single missed cost might lead to her dropping her house.

Rojo mentioned she understands her obligation to pay taxes and is dedicated to assembly it. She needs she requested her household for assist sooner and was extra proactive; even a high-interest mortgage would have been cheaper than delinquency. However whereas the household is dedicated to paying its debt, the attorneys charges add a burden they see as pointless.

“We’re not looking to scapegoat the county or scapegoat the law firm. We got into this mess ourselves,” Ryan Rojo mentioned. “I would just advocate for a deeper sense of justice.”

About this story:

To report this story, the Tribune contacted the tax assessor-collectors or appraisal districts in all 254 Texas counties to find out which outsourced delinquent property tax assortment. To acquire the lawyer price information for delinquent property tax assortment inside the 100 most populous counties, the Tribune despatched 334 information requests for contracts with the non-public legislation companies in addition to cost information. Inside a few of these counties, some cities and college districts handle their very own property tax assortment, so the Tribune obtained lawyer price information from these entities straight. The Tribune recognized sources for this story from publicly out there county delinquent tax rolls. Journalists visited Ector, Montgomery, Franklin, Travis and Harris counties. To conduct the assessment of delinquent tax assortment insurance policies throughout the nation, they contacted state and native tax assortment officers in all 50 states.

In case you have a tip or expertise to share about delinquent tax assortment or one other type of debt assortment in Texas, contact Zach Despart at zach.despart@texastribune.org.

---

We are able to’t wait to welcome you to the fifteenth annual Texas Tribune Competition, Texas’ breakout concepts and politics occasion taking place Nov. 13–15 in downtown Austin. Step contained in the conversations shaping the way forward for schooling, the economic system, well being care, power, know-how, public security, tradition, the humanities and a lot extra.

Hear from our CEO, Sonal Shah, on TribFest 2025.

TribFest 2025 is offered by JPMorganChase.