A professional-gun, anti-abortion border sheriff appealed to each events. Then he was painted as gentle on immigration.

Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s day by day publication that retains readers in control on probably the most important Texas information.

---

DEL RIO — In 2008, Joe Frank Martinez beat a Republican incumbent to grow to be the primary Latino elected sheriff alongside this 110-mile stretch of border. Almost 16 years later, in mid-September, Martinez stood in entrance of a number of dozen voters on the San Felipe Lions Membership, having to marketing campaign tougher than ever earlier than, and on a difficulty that wasn’t a consider his earlier elections: immigration.

The 68-year-old Democrat had been in regulation enforcement for almost 5 a long time, and save for a bit of greater than a 12 months when he was stationed elsewhere as a state trooper, Martinez advised the viewers, he’d spent them guaranteeing the protection of residents in Val Verde County. He had mastered politics on this place almost three hours south of San Antonio, the place residents prided themselves on voting for the individual they favored greatest as an alternative of a celebration. He’d handily received every of his elections and ran unopposed 4 years in the past when the county tipped for Donald Trump.

Since then, it had been a tumultuous time, Martinez acknowledged to these assembled within the cafeteria-like area. They’d gone by way of a pandemic. They’d contended with a winter storm that had left a whole lot of Texans lifeless. After which, he mentioned, “We faced the Haitians.”

He didn’t clarify what he meant, and he didn’t must. The reminiscence of almost 20,000 primarily Haitian immigrants — the equal of greater than half of the inhabitants in Del Rio — arriving on the border virtually abruptly and held underneath the worldwide bridge for 2 weeks in September 2021 has been seared into the minds of residents right here. Many feared it might occur once more and questioned whether or not Martinez was powerful sufficient on immigration.

Immigration isn’t a part of Martinez’s job. However in Del Rio, like in different majority Latino border communities throughout the nation, the problem is excessive on voters’ minds and is disrupting long-standing political allegiances. The barrel-chested lawman with a booming voice has skilled these disruptions firsthand. In a neighborhood the place about 80% of residents are Latino, some had begun portray the Democratic sheriff as gentle on immigration and falsely accused him of aiding unauthorized crossings.

Generally the assaults occurred overtly. When he pulled immigrants who had arrived on the banks of the river out of the water to maintain them from drowning, Republicans accused him of serving to folks enter the nation illegally. Some residents, together with supporters, criticized Martinez on social media once they discovered he could be endorsed by the Bexar County sheriff based mostly in San Antonio who, throughout a speech on the Democratic Nationwide Conference, referred to as Trump self-serving and accused the previous president of constructing border sheriffs’ jobs tougher when he killed a bipartisan border safety deal earlier this 12 months.

Different occasions, a few of those that turned in opposition to Martinez did so with out saying a phrase. An indication he positioned at a longtime pal’s home had been changed by one along with his opponent’s slogan about “bringing order to the border.”

Standing in entrance of the gang gathered on the Lions Membership, Martinez shared a dizzying array of charts he’d introduced alongside to reply to his critics. Issues had been so as on the border. Val Verde was seeing a number of the lowest numbers of immigrants crossing in years, even decrease than in neighboring counties the place sheriffs had gone so far as to permit militias to function.

As for whether or not the Haitian migrant episode might occur once more — the query he knew was looming in folks’s minds — he reminded them that it was federal authorities, not his workplace, who managed border crossings.

He was as upset as they had been with President Joe Biden’s response, and he’d been very public about saying as a lot. He hoped that when it got here to the race for sheriff, they’d decide him on how he’d dealt with the tasks assigned to him. How he’d served Val Verde, like his father earlier than him, as a lawman, neighbor, husband and father; that who he was outweighed his affiliation with any get together.

This time, nonetheless, he wasn’t certain the pitch would work.

“I want to try to keep my campaign at the local level,” Martinez mentioned in an interview.

“I might be blind to the fact that it can’t be done.”

Shifting politics

It’s lengthy been understood that the Latino vote is neither monolithic nor reliably Democratic. Locations similar to Del Rio, a deeply Catholic border metropolis whose financial system relies upon closely on regulation enforcement jobs, have all the time held conservative views. Republicans like former President George W. Bush received right here by interesting to these views whereas arguing for a compassionate method to immigration.

Till lately, the get together’s far-right shift on immigration hadn’t managed to make vital inroads in border communities. Conservative assertions concerning the situation, significantly those who painted immigration as an “invasion,” had didn’t resonate with folks on the border exactly as a result of they knew higher from residing there. To them, the border was a basic characteristic of their day-to-day lives and an engine of their economies, not one thing to be afraid of. A decade in the past, the overwhelming majority of immigrants who crossed the border had been from Mexico. And nearly all of the Latinos residing on america facet of the border had roots in Mexico as properly.

That’s modified, as produce other immigration patterns on the border, and so have the attitudes of those that stay right here. Democratic politics have been sluggish to maintain up — not less than rhetorically — with these shifts. However Republicans have seized on them to maneuver extra voters into their camp. The state’s Republican Get together now not makes an attempt to strike a steadiness on immigration. In reality, throughout this presidential cycle, it has gone even additional through the use of the problem as a litmus check for whether or not it may possibly flip border communities crimson, not simply of their decisions for state and federal candidates however for native ones too.

Starting in 2014, the numbers of Central American households and unaccompanied minors arriving on the border began to extend. The sight of juveniles held in makeshift camps on space army bases stirred political tensions in border communities and past. Later, the border grew to become floor zero for Trump’s anti-immigration efforts, which concerned separating kids from their mother and father and forcing Central American asylum-seekers to stay in Mexico till they got a date to seem in U.S. immigration courtroom. Neither of these efforts had a long-lasting affect on the variety of folks arriving on the border, however they pressured extra immigrants to be caught on the Mexican facet for longer intervals of time — and disruptions on the Mexican facet of the border virtually all the time ripple into the U.S. facet.

In an unprecedented effort to assist america maintain immigrants from arriving on the border, Mexico started detaining them and transporting them farther south. It additionally allowed america to show again Mexican nationals and a few Central People, however not most different immigrants. When phrase received out amongst would-be immigrants in South America, West Africa, China and Haiti, they started arriving in such massive numbers that they overwhelmed the border, together with a number of of the U.S. cities and cities the place they in the end landed.

The hundreds of Haitians who arrived in Del Rio three years in the past shook town as a result of it was like nothing folks there had skilled in current historical past. And like Martinez, plenty of residents right here have histories that return a good distance.

His grandparents migrated from Italy and Mexico greater than 100 years in the past, attracted by the world’s fertile land and ranches. One grandmother fled instability and violence main as much as the Mexican Revolution. Rising up, Martinez remembers immigrants knocking on the door of his household’s residence, asking for a meal and short-term work. Generally that meant rather less meals on the desk or that the shed within the yard received yet one more recent coat of paint it didn’t really want.

Martinez and his 9 siblings discovered to maneuver simply in two cultures.

“My dad always emphasized to us: We’re in this country, we’re Americans first,” mentioned his brother Leonel Martinez Jr., 67, who runs a binational firm that makes leather-based horse saddles in Ciudad Acuña, Mexico, and sells them in america. “He also stressed that we should never forget our roots.”

A staunch Catholic and Democrat, the household patriarch looms massive within the decisions the siblings make. He was energetic in combating for equal rights at a time when Mexican People had been excluded from many actions and didn’t have a voice in authorities. He co-founded a civic group to assist convey sewer traces, paved roads and mailboxes to his predominantly Mexican American neighborhood; helped elect town’s first Mexican American mayor; and dreamed of changing into the primary elected Hispanic sheriff for Del Rio — a dream he held on to till his loss of life on the age of 51.

Due to him, the brothers are Democrats too, however in various methods.

Leonel, who wears a goatee and goes by Leo, voted for Barack Obama after which voted twice for Trump, saying he aligns extra intently with the latter on the financial system and immigration. He believes U.S. coverage has grow to be such that it’s simpler for folks from far-off nations to return and keep than it’s for Mexicans.

“Why would you do that?” he mentioned. “I mean, if I see my neighbor having a problem, he’s the first one I think I want to help. If I see somebody on the other side of the world that needs help, I don’t know.”

One other brother, David, was elected 4 years in the past as Val Verde county lawyer. The 60-year-old with graying hair is among the many extra progressive of his siblings. He opposed efforts to prosecute some folks searching for asylum and mentioned that so far as he’s involved, what’s been happening on the border isn’t an immigration disaster. It’s “a human crisis.” And in responding to it, he mentioned whereas choking again tears, “We can’t be inhuman. We can’t put our compassion aside.”

Joe Frank, whose given title is Jose Francisco, straddles his brothers’ views. He’s pro-gun, is anti-abortion and has a son who works as a Border Patrol agent. He believes that there needs to be a path for folks to make their case for beginning new lives in america however that the present system is simply too chaotic and doesn’t transfer quick sufficient to take away those that don’t qualify.

That place had all the time labored for him amongst voters as a result of that’s the place they gave the impression to be too — till the Haitian immigrants arrived.

Unfolding disaster

On a cold morning in January 2021, Martinez stood on the fringe of the riverbank as a rescue boat introduced within the physique of a 33-year-old Haitian girl. She wore crimson tennis footwear and blue and white basketball shorts. Her shirt was pushed above her bulging stomach. The girl, who drowned whereas attempting to succeed in Del Rio, had carried twin infants almost to time period.

Martinez was shaken by the lack of three lives abruptly. He felt folks both didn’t know or didn’t care what was happening on the border.

He started capturing images on his telephone of the disaster he noticed unfolding earlier than him: mother and father with their infants struggling to wade by way of the Rio Grande and different immigrants who weren’t fortunate sufficient to outlive the river’s currents. There have been additionally the photographs of a human smuggler who was arrested thrice after she stored getting launched, younger women touring alone and a high-speed chase that left eight immigrants lifeless.

Within the months that adopted, Border Patrol encounters within the Del Rio sector, which stretches 245 miles alongside the Rio Grande by way of Val Verde and two different border counties, doubled from 11,000 that January to just about 22,000 in April 2021. Annoyed, Martinez wrote his first-ever opinion piece, for USA In the present day. In it, he referred to as on Washington politicians to go to his county relatively than simply cross by way of for a photograph alternative, and he pleaded with them to place their egos apart and cross complete immigration reform.

“If they could stay a few days and see the madness and mayhem going on right now, there’d be no more wasting time trying to decide whether the border situation is a ‘crisis’ or not,” he wrote. “If they could have witnessed my deputies pull a full-term pregnant woman’s body out of the Rio Grande, maybe they could put their differences aside.”

It wasn’t only a humanitarian situation, Martinez defined in an interview on Fox Information that month. It was a useful resource situation. “When I have four deputies working, and three of them are tied up for the majority part of the day, we can’t serve our citizens and our community the way we need to be serving them,” he advised the cable information community.

No Washington decision-makers visited. Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, nonetheless, seized the second. A loyal Trump supporter and one in all Biden’s fiercest critics, Abbott traveled to Del Rio that June to carry a border safety summit. He praised Martinez, saying he appreciated “all that he and every man and woman involved in law enforcement are doing, especially to step up and help secure our border.”

The governor described what was occurring as an invasion. He then introduced that the state would construct its personal wall and arrest immigrants for trespassing as a part of Operation Lone Star, a multibillion-dollar state initiative he’d launched earlier that 12 months. “We are going to do everything we can to secure the border,” Abbott mentioned to a boisterous crowd, “and it begins immediately today right here in Val Verde County.”

However three months later, little had modified.

Immigrants began to reach in Del Rio by the a whole lot, then by the hundreds. As a substitute of being processed and leaving town virtually as quickly as they arrived, as they sometimes did, they waited with Border Patrol-issued color-coded raffle-like tickets for the chance to show themselves over to federal authorities so they might request authorized protections, together with asylum.

They lay on items of cardboard underneath makeshift tents original from river cane they’d lower from the banks of the Rio Grande. Dad and mom and their kids vomited and handed out from dehydration within the triple-digit warmth. There have been no showers, and solely about one transportable rest room was out there for each 140 folks.

Some Del Rio residents requested how they might assist, whereas others referred to as for the instant deportation of all the immigrants. One girl fired her revolver within the path of a gaggle of Haitians, claiming she had panicked.

The swift and sudden arrival of so many immigrants additionally examined the Martinez household.

When the federal authorities introduced the short-term closure of the worldwide bridge, Leo Martinez referred to as the sheriff, hoping that his brother had data on how lengthy the closure would final. Joe Frank Martinez didn’t know.

Whereas he waited to be taught extra, Leo Martinez was pressured to divert U.S. deliveries of saddles by way of one other worldwide bridge greater than 50 miles away, the place the motive force needed to wait upwards of 12 hours to cross. The closure value the corporate a number of thousand {dollars} in gas and extra employees time.

“We are pawns in this game that the federal government’s playing,” mentioned Leo Martinez, a self-described ultra-super-conservative Democrat, later including that very like in a recreation of chess, border residents are “the ones that you sacrifice up front.”

The Sunday after the bridge closed, David Martinez, the county’s prime lawyer, was packing for a convention when he received a name from a metropolis official. Abbott needed police to arrest hundreds of immigrants underneath the bridge for trespassing, and town official requested if he would prosecute them.

The county lawyer didn’t straight say no, however his response left little doubt.

The federal authorities had created the circumstances that had brought on the immigrants to stay there, he advised town official. It had introduced in transportable bathrooms and supplied some meals and water. For police to arrest them, officers wanted to make it clear they had been now not allowed on metropolis property. In addition to, the county lawyer mentioned, the crushing workload on his three-person authorized group would inevitably result in a backlog that will drive immigrants to remain in detention longer than is authorized. With out correct discover, “I would have been violating people’s constitutional rights by the thousands, and I wasn’t willing to do it.”

Two days later, Abbott was again in Del Rio, the place he accused Biden and Vice President Kamala Harris of “promoting and allowing open-border policies.” He touted the arrests of immigrants underneath his state initiative, one which counted work that had nothing to do with the border as a part of its metrics for fulfillment.

The sheriff stood behind him.

Shedding floor

Whereas on his option to a physician’s appointment final fall, Joe Frank Martinez received a name from an unknown quantity. It was a Republican operative inviting him to run on behalf of the opposite group.

The state’s Republican leaders, together with its two U.S. senators, liked him, Martinez recalled the operative telling him. He’d taken positions as conservative as theirs on the problems they cared most about. If he agreed to modify events, the political motion committee would cowl his submitting charges and assist fund his marketing campaign.

He’d definitely had critical variations with Democrats lately. The get together had modified in methods he didn’t like. However leaving felt an excessive amount of like a dishonor, not solely to his father’s reminiscence, however to his beliefs.

He mentioned no.

Shortly afterward, the PAC, generally known as Undertaking Crimson TX, positioned its assist behind a 56-year-old police officer named Rogelio “Roger” Hernandez. The Republican challenger was born in Del Rio however had spent his regulation enforcement profession in San Antonio. Hernandez mentioned he was planning to retire and transfer again to the border metropolis to be close to his mother. He couldn’t recall if Undertaking Crimson TX approached him or if he approached the group.

Undertaking Crimson TX started to extra aggressively goal border communities after Trump made features within the historically Democratic strongholds throughout the 2020 presidential election. The group, which helps elect Republicans in native races in Latino communities, has raised greater than $2.5 million. The majority of that cash comes from a political motion committee whose largest donors embrace Texas actual property businessmen Harlan Crow and Richard Weekley.

This 12 months alone, the group has spent about $370,000 on promoting for about 50 native candidates, primarily in border counties, in response to marketing campaign finance experiences. Three of the candidates, together with Hernandez, are in Val Verde County.

The message appears to be resonating. This 12 months, for the primary time in a long time, extra folks voted within the Val Verde County Republican main than within the Democratic main — in reality, twice as many did.

As a part of his marketing campaign to convey “order to the border,” Hernandez has promised to safe extra sources for the sheriff’s workplace.

“I’ll get them better training, better equipment, better vehicles, better everything,” Hernandez mentioned, with out providing specifics on how he would meet that promise, saying solely “there’s grants out there that you can get.”

Martinez mentioned his workplace has labored diligently to safe out there grants, together with these which are designated for border safety. Altogether, Val Verde County and town of Del Rio have acquired greater than $13 million in state and federal grants since 2021, about half of which may be attributed to Operation Lone Star. That exceeds what they received in whole the earlier 13 years.

“That individual hasn’t lived here in over 30 years, and all of a sudden he shows up in the ninth inning. Come on, give me a break,” Martinez mentioned.

Because the race heated up this summer time, Wayne Hamilton, a longtime Texas Republican operative who heads Undertaking Crimson TX, posted a photograph of himself and Hernandez on social media. Behind them was a stack of the candidate’s marketing campaign indicators. Hernandez was dedicated to frame safety, Hamilton wrote, then added, “The incumbent Sheriff was featured in a documentary helping migrants enter the country illegally. It’s time for change.”

Hamilton declined a number of interview requests and didn’t reply to questions concerning the race or about which documentary he was referring to. Information footage from the 2021 immigration spike reveals Martinez extending his hand to assist folks within the Rio Grande, who had already reached the U.S., safely onto land. He then turned these immigrants over to Border Patrol.

“Once you are in the United States, in the middle of that river, I’ve got to protect you,” Martinez mentioned, questioning what folks would have mentioned if he hadn’t executed so and one of many immigrants had drowned. “It’s a human being at the end of the day.”

The assaults are significantly upsetting for Martinez, who prides himself on having mates from the precise and left. Amongst Martinez’s backers is the Republican sheriff he beat in 2008. “It’s about relationships, something I’ve been building since 1977,” he mentioned.

A few of these relationships turned out to be extra fragile than Martinez was conscious.

On a current afternoon in mid-September, Mary Fritz, a fourth-generation rancher and Trump supporter, picked up an indication for his opponent throughout a meet-and-greet at an area burger restaurant.

Fritz, a petite 62-year-old with weathered pores and skin, and Martinez have been mates for about 4 a long time. She has voted for him each time — even in opposition to Republicans.

He’s an excellent sheriff, Fritz says. She appreciates how he’s available and out in the neighborhood the place constituents can speak to him and voice their considerations. “I just wish he would have pressed the border issue more,” Fritz mentioned as she walked on a patch of the two,000 acres of desert scrubland that abuts the Rio Grande the place her household raises sheep and goats.

Martinez didn’t maintain again his frustration. If voters had been prepared to ignore his a long time of service and decide him on one thing he had no management over, “God bless them.”

Damaged system

When politicians, authorities bureaucrats or reporters come to Del Rio and ask the sheriff to point out them whether or not the billions of {dollars} spent by successive presidents have made the border safer, he piles them into his white Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck and drives them all the way down to the so-called wall in order that they’ll see for themselves.

“All this right here,” Martinez says, pointing to an expanse of land the place ranches as soon as stood a couple of mile north of the Rio Grande, “used to be little ranchitos that went all the way to the river. I think the U.S. government made something like 13 millionaires when they purchased all this property.”

Of their place, there may be now a jumble of fencing.

The black wrought iron panels about 14 toes tall had been erected throughout the administration of former President George W. Bush, who was attempting to funnel immigrants into areas the place Border Patrol might extra simply catch them. Martinez thinks these labored.

The Trump administration tore down a few of them to construct sections twice as excessive of the “big, beautiful wall” he promised voters. However Trump left workplace earlier than finishing the venture. Biden then got here in and instantly paused development, pledging to not construct “another foot” of wall. In Del Rio, that meant that staff left stacks of development supplies behind and gaps between the panels of fencing extensive sufficient for tractor-trailers to drive by way of them. The Biden administration tried to shut these gaps by hanging flimsy wire mesh that’s already sagging in some areas from folks climbing over it.

For Martinez, all of this displays a political system bent on combating over border safety relatively than reaching it.

“Do we really have a system that’s broken, or do we have a political machine that’s broken?” he mentioned. “The far right is pushing and the far left is trying to push back, but what happened to working together?”

Answering his personal query, he later mentioned, “We’re going to continue with this mess probably long after I’m dead and gone.”