A surge in bee deaths is hurting Texas beekeepers — and will have an effect on the worth of produce

Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s each day publication that retains readers in control on essentially the most important Texas information.

---

Since beginning their beekeeping enterprise southwest of San Antonio in late 2019, the Wheeler household has aimed to supply about 3,000 bee colonies every year, a lot of that are used to pollinate crops like watermelons and pumpkins.

Within the final 15 years, bee colony collapses have develop into extra widespread. It is typical for the Wheelers’ Frio Nation Farms to lose about half of their bees every year. However final yr, that development worsened and the rising variety of useless bees is hurting their monetary backside line.

The losses have gotten so unhealthy that the Wheelers are contemplating pivoting away from pollination companies towards honey manufacturing, mentioned co-owner Ryan Wheeler, 36, within the hopes that it’ll assist the bees keep “healthy and strong.” Farmers all through the nation depend on beekeepers just like the Wheelers to develop bees to pollinate greater than 100 varieties of vegatables and fruits.

“I just don’t really know why, but [the number of bee deaths] was definitely elevated this year,” Wheeler mentioned. “I’m hoping that it’s nothing terrible, but it sounds scary when you hear all of the reports.”

The Wheeler household’s operation is without doubt one of the hundreds experiencing what consultants are calling a number of the heaviest bee losses in latest reminiscence. Since June, industrial beekeepers in Texas have misplaced about two thirds of their bee colonies on common, in accordance with a survey revealed final month that was administered by Mission Apis m., a honey bee analysis nonprofit. Business beekeepers throughout the nation misplaced about 62% of their bees — with no obvious purpose — in the identical interval, the survey additionally mentioned.

The monetary losses to beekeepers nationwide go as much as $635 million, the survey added. Consultants fear the colony collapses are unsustainable and can have a series impact on fruit and vegetable progress that can affect shoppers. They are saying having fewer bees to pollinate this yr can reduce the standard and amount of meals that depend on pollination like watermelon, berries and, particularly, almonds.

Heavy bee losses in a single season can even affect the beekeepers’ potential to develop extra within the subsequent, inflicting a “trickle-down effect,” mentioned Geoffrey Williams, an agriculture professor at Auburn College who co-authors a yearly survey on bee losses every year.

“This is one of the years where, from what I’ve heard through the grapevine, these beekeepers may not even recover,” Williams mentioned. “In some cases, I think we’re going to lose beekeeping companies because they had to essentially just throw in the towel.”

Influence on Texas beekeepers and shoppers

The heavy losses up to now yr are anticipated to have an outsized affect on Texas, which is without doubt one of the nation’s high beekeeping states. Texas has had considerably of a beekeeping renaissance in latest a long time, with the variety of beekeeping firms within the state greater than quadrupling from 1,851 to eight,939 from 2012 to 2022, in accordance with a Washington Put up evaluation of census knowledge.

Along with having a comparatively delicate local weather superb for rising bees, the state turned a lovely location for the trade due to a 2012 legislation that provides tax breaks to those that preserve bees on at the very least 5 of their acres.

However heavy losses lately threaten a number of the beekeeping positive factors the state has made. The colony collapses have impacted even a number of the largest honey bee outfits in Texas, hurting their income and talent to supply sufficient bees to their companions in California for almond pollination. Almond crops are absolutely depending on bee pollination.

For a lot of beekeeping firms in Texas, sending bees to pollinate almonds in California represents a excessive portion of their earnings early within the yr. Some firms, just like the Wheelers’ Frio Nation Farms, weren’t in a position to ship bees to pollinate in California this yr. Others, like Tim Hollmann’s greater than 40-year-old beekeeping enterprise, needed to ship over a a lot smaller provide than ordinary.

Hollmann, 62, has operated Hollmann Apiaries since 1984, however bees have been part of his life for even longer. In working a small bee outfit together with his father throughout his teenage years, Hollmann mentioned he was in a position to put himself by faculty on the College of South Dakota.

At present, he’s answerable for rising hundreds of bee colonies every year. Although his enterprise relies in South Dakota, about half of its operations are in Texas. Earlier than Hollmann’s bees are shipped off to California in early February to pollinate almonds, they’re nurtured in Texas for a number of months. However Hollmann has struggled to fulfill his quota over the previous few years, and it’s unclear why that has been the case.

“We’ve lost some serious ground here last year that certainly we’re not going to make up for this year,” Hollmann mentioned. “In fact, we’re going to fall further behind.”

Whereas he led to 6,750 bee colonies to Texas late final fall, he was solely in a position to ship about 1,800 to California for almond pollination earlier this month. With about 124 colonies remaining in Texas, Hollmann mentioned greater than 70% of his bees died up to now yr, exceeding the nationwide common. He can’t bear in mind experiencing losses ever that top earlier than.

Beekeepers and consultants within the area have in contrast latest losses to a phenomenon that occurred closely within the late 2000s referred to as Colony Collapse Dysfunction, or CCD. First reported in 2006, CCD happens when a majority of employee bees in a colony abruptly disappear. Within the late 2000s, honeybee colony losses jumped from about 10-15% on common to 30-50% every year. Loss averages haven’t improved since.

“The beekeeping industry has been warning for almost 20 years that we’re going to pass a point of no return at some point,” mentioned Blake Shook, a Texas beekeeper who co-founded a enterprise that helps others within the bee enterprise.

The excessive losses over the previous yr, Shook mentioned, may affect the worth of fruits, greens and different meals reliant on bee pollination for progress. Fruit and veggies like apples, blueberries, pumpkins and watermelons, may have their high quality “greatly diminished” by heavy bee losses, he added. Texas is one of many 4 largest watermelon-producing states within the nation, coming behind Florida, Georgia and California.

“Bees are the backbone of agriculture,” he added. “All things that make food delicious and nutritious come from honey bees. ”

No clear trigger for losses

Whereas the heavier bee losses are placing beekeeping operations and producers in danger, it’s nonetheless unclear what the underlying causes are or how they are often reversed. However bee consultants say there are just a few potential culprits.

In line with Garett Slater, one of many state’s main honey bee specialists at Texas A&M College, there are sometimes 5 key explanation why honey bee colonies collapse: parasites just like the Varroa mite, pathogens, pesticides, poor diet among the many bees and weak queen bees, who’re answerable for maintaining bee colonies unified and laying eggs. The reason for latest losses is probably going a mix of those components, mentioned Slater, who works immediately with beekeepers to assist forestall colony collapse.

Varroa mites particularly have been a standard pest for honey bees, Slater added. The mites are sometimes in a position to unfold viruses that honey bees aren’t proof against, he mentioned, making it troublesome to handle the issue. Slater added that Texas A&M is at present working with america Division of Agriculture to assist breed bees which are immune to varroa mites.

In contrast to the mid-to-late 2000s, Texas and the U.S. are higher ready to handle the heavier bee losses at the moment and uncover why they’re occurring. Slater mentioned. His place at Texas A&M is comparatively new and started in June. Within the position, he supervises specialists all through the state who promote sustainable beekeeping practices.

Even previous to this previous yr, the losses beekeepers had been dealing with was “already unsustainable,” Slater mentioned. Extra frequent and constant losses shifting ahead would already heighten the issues beekeepers are already dealing with, he added.

“If 70% losses become the new norm, that could directly impact pollination, that could directly impact honey production, [and] that could directly impact bee sales to local beekeepers and groups across the state,” Slater mentioned. “So it could have a huge impact locally in Texas but even across the nation.”

Juliana Rangel, a professor of entomology at Texas A&M, mentioned the losses beekeepers are seeing are probably not resulting from any human error. The beekeepers she’s engaged with haven’t modified their practices all that a lot since final yr, she mentioned, suggesting that one other issue is probably going at play.

Hollmann, who has been within the trade for greater than 40 years, can also be at a loss about what’s inflicting the colony losses. He has his suspicions, particularly that the Varroa mite is perhaps inflicting havoc or colonies aren’t adequately supporting their queen bees.

However he additionally has greater image worries. Hollmann feels that continued excessive losses might dissuade individuals from becoming a member of the trade, which performs an important position in sustaining the meals ecosystem and serving to to develop dietary meals within the U.S. and throughout the globe.

“I’m just not sure we’re going to get the young, talented individuals to want to carry on this industry for the next generation and generations beyond,” he mentioned. “I’m seriously worried about that.”

Disclosure: Apple and Texas A&M College have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partly by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no position within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.

---

We are able to’t wait to welcome you to the fifteenth annual Texas Tribune Competition, Texas’ breakout concepts and politics occasion occurring Nov. 13–15 in downtown Austin. Step contained in the conversations shaping the way forward for training, the financial system, well being care, vitality, expertise, public security, tradition, the humanities and a lot extra.

Hear from our CEO, Sonal Shah, on TribFest 2025.

TribFest 2025 is offered by JPMorganChase.