As Texas refuses on-line voter registration, paper functions get misplaced

Join the We the Texans publication to obtain twice-monthly updates on our year-long initiative devoted to boosting civic engagement and chronicling how democracy is skilled in Texas.

---

This protection is made potential by means of Votebeat, a nonpartisan information group protecting native election administration and voting entry. Join Votebeat Texas’ free newsletters right here. This story was produced with assist from the Pulitzer Heart.

Final 12 months, Hannah Murry remembers, she stuffed out each line of her paper voter registration.

She then gave it to a volunteer deputy registrar at a registration drive at Texas A&M College-Corpus Christi, the place she’s a pupil.

“I thought that was handled, so I just went on with my life,” mentioned Murry.

It wasn’t dealt with.

Murry, 21, discovered that out when she went to an early voting location in Nueces County final fall to solid her first poll, within the constitutional modification election.

She handed her ID to an election employee — who advised her she wasn’t on the rolls.

At that time, it was too late to repair it. Ballot staff let her replace her registration on website for the subsequent election, which she did. She left confused and annoyed.

“I went there able to vote, able to be engaged, after which I used to be not in a position to,” she mentioned.

The identical factor occurs to individuals throughout Texas, a Votebeat investigation discovered: Eligible voters who imagine they’ve completed all the things essential to solid a poll don’t get the possibility as a result of their registrations didn’t make it into the system.

There isn’t any easy method to know the way many individuals are disenfranchised due to this, however greater than a dozen native election officers and volunteer deputy registrars shared examples, and a number of individuals advised related tales: They stuffed out the paper utility kind, mailed it, gave it to a volunteer deputy registrar, and even went to their county workplace to drop it off — and nonetheless weren’t efficiently registered.

Votebeat’s investigation discovered the issues apparently share a root trigger: a registration system that depends on paper varieties. Texas is one among solely eight states with out universally obtainable on-line voter registration. Most individuals within the state need to fill out a paper kind, whether or not they’re registering by means of an election workplace or whereas getting a brand new driver’s license or state ID on the Texas Division of Public Security. Solely individuals who have already got a Texas driver’s license and are participating in an internet transaction with DPS, akin to renewing their license or updating their deal with, can use a DPS on-line portal to register.

The Texas Secretary of State’s workplace advised Votebeat that providing on-line registration to all voters would require legislative motion. State lawmakers have for years resisted efforts to take action.

Meaning data from a whole lot of hundreds of functions processed every year needs to be entered into county election programs by hand — creating loads of alternatives for issues to go improper.

Makes an attempt to register by way of DPS, which handles roughly 2 million voter registrations a 12 months, additionally didn’t all the time work. Public data obtained by Votebeat by way of a data request present election officers from at the least 41 totally different counties contacted the company throughout both the November 2022 normal election or this 12 months’s major about greater than 100 individuals who mentioned they registered at DPS, however didn’t make it onto the rolls. Dozens of different inquiries to the company sought details about voters whose DPS functions have been incomplete, data present.

Election officers say the amount will increase throughout presidential election years, making it extra probably that some registrations may slip by means of the cracks.

“You want to be able to tell people, ‘You can do this, you can fill this out, check this box and you’ll be fine’ and that ‘Yes, you can trust in this system,’” mentioned Valerie DeBill, vice chairman of voter companies on the League of Ladies Voters in Austin, and a volunteer deputy registrar. “And it just doesn’t seem to really work the way that it’s supposed to.”

Volunteer deputy registrars, just like the one who collected Murry’s utility on campus, are legally required to deliver all accomplished functions to county election officers. However that doesn’t be sure that they get correctly recorded.

In Murry’s case, Nueces County acquired the shape, in response to Brenda Nuñez, the county’s voter registration supervisor, but it surely did not replace her report to exchange an earlier registration in Jefferson County.

Murry mentioned she didn’t obtain something within the mail after updating her data on the polls, however in the end registered efficiently by means of one other volunteer deputy registrar she knew personally. She voted within the major earlier this 12 months in Nueces County.

“We research. We do the best we can to read voters’ handwriting, and to try to reach them to correct an issue [with the application] so they don’t get rejected, but it doesn’t always work,” mentioned Nuñez, including that voters additionally make errors. “They can transpose a number or forget to check a box. But we can make errors, too. We try to do our best, but it can happen.”

Errors and hurdles can gradual registration

Texans should be registered to vote at the least 30 days earlier than the date of an election. Clean functions that voters can print out and full can be found on-line, in addition to in any U.S. put up workplace, at workplaces of the Well being and Human Companies Fee, the Texas Workforce Fee, and DPS, and at public libraries. Or voters can get them at registration drives at group occasions or school campuses.

County officers answerable for voter registration have staff assigned to course of the varieties as they arrive in. That features manually coming into the knowledge on them into the county’s database. The functions are then scanned as pictures, and the bodily varieties are shredded as soon as the registration is accepted and the voter registration certificates is mailed. Giant counties akin to Travis and Collin rent a number of momentary staff to assist staffers course of registrations.

In Nueces County, which has greater than 200,000 registered voters, Nuñez has two different full-time workers members and brings in 4 momentary staff to assist them course of the a whole lot of varieties that arrive day by day throughout an election season. Retired metropolis staff alphabetize the functions, verify them line by line, and enter the knowledge into the system.

Final week, as early voting received underway, Nuñez and her workers have been flooded with telephone calls from voters. Some mentioned they tried to vote and couldn’t as a result of they weren’t on the rolls. Others known as as a result of they have been registered in one other county and didn’t replace their data on time.

Errors on functions gradual issues down, and staff can’t all the time attain the applicant to repair them in time for the subsequent election.

At a September voter registration drive in Corpus Christi, a voter stuffed out his utility and left. Whereas reviewing it, volunteer deputy registrar Alex Flucke realized the voter had made a mistake on the road deal with. However the voter didn’t depart a telephone quantity. In a case like this, election staff might attempt to lookup the right deal with, utilizing maps and different assets. They’ll additionally probably mail the possible voter a discover — although the wrong deal with may maintain it from being delivered.

Flucke, 29, who’s the vice chairman of voter companies with the League of Ladies Voters in Corpus Christi, mentioned candidates make errors on a regular basis. “People don’t put their address, people don’t know their address, people don’t have their driver’s license, especially at high schools, and a lot of times they don’t know the last four [digits] of their Social Security number,” Flucke mentioned.

She’s seen voters who neglect to verify the containers on the high of the applying asking whether or not they’re at the least 18 years previous and a U.S. citizen.

“Every issue that you can experience with people filling out those forms, I’ve seen,” Flucke mentioned.

Volunteer deputy registrars play an necessary function within the course of, particularly in bigger counties, the place they assist generate a big quantity of registrations by means of group outreach. However there are a lot of steps they have to comply with. Texas has strict legal guidelines requiring anybody registering voters for a county to be licensed as a volunteer deputy registrar in that county. Some counties supply on-line coaching, whereas different counties’ require coaching in individual.

There’s no method to change into licensed statewide, which implies volunteer deputy registrars typically can’t settle for functions from individuals who stay in neighboring counties. They’ll supply a kind from the Secretary of State’s workplace, however the voter should mail it again to that workplace, which forwards it to the voter’s county. Two weeks after the voter registration deadline, some counties have been nonetheless receiving functions within the mail from the Secretary of State’s workplace.

Volunteer deputy registrars flip in all of the varieties they acquire to county election officers, like Shannon Lackey, the elections administrator in Randall County.

“So many times those applications come in to us and they are nearly illegible, and so we are having to guess what their name is,” Lackey mentioned. Usually voters don’t notice that they need to put their authorized identify or precisely because it seems on their Social Safety card, state ID or driver’s license, she added.

Voter registration functions go astray

Since 2021, greater than 2 million Texans have yearly registered to vote by means of DPS, both by means of the paper varieties or the net portal obtainable to individuals who renew or replace their state IDs or licenses. In simply the primary eight months of this 12 months, that determine surpassed 3 million individuals.

However DPS staff can’t immediately add somebody to the voter rolls. The knowledge they acquire needs to be conveyed first to native election officers by means of the state’s voter registration system, TEAM.

Typically, the knowledge goes astray. In different instances, election officers advised Votebeat, these functions are transmitted with out the voter’s deal with, or with incorrect road names — data that election officers will need to have to assign voters to the right precinct.

Sufficient registrations go astray that TEAM has a chosen portal for election officers to submit inquiries to DPS about lacking registrations. It’s additionally used to double-check a voter’s deal with or driver’s license quantity when that data is lacking or unclear. There’s additionally a chosen e-mail deal with for such requests. Information obtained by Votebeat present a gradual stream of inquiries.

“The following voters stated that they registered through DPS in order to change their address prior to October 11, 2022,” Cynthia Lum, the election official from Houston County (inhabitants round 22,000), wrote in an e-mail, itemizing 11 voters and asking the company to verify its data.

In an interview, Lum mentioned that 2022 was the primary time the county had such a excessive variety of lacking functions tied to DPS, and that the company has improved.

As for the 11 voters she requested about in 2022, she couldn’t say what the response was from DPS in every case. However she mentioned such voters can solid a provisional poll that will get counted as soon as DPS is ready to discover and ahead their accomplished registrations. Those that didn’t verify “yes” on the small field asking in the event that they wished to replace their voter registration stay ineligible, and their provisional ballots aren’t counted.

In November 2022, election officers in East Texas’ Nacogdoches County requested DPS about greater than a dozen voters’ functions. Anderson County officers sought functions for 21 voters who mentioned they’d registered at DPS however weren’t on the rolls and needed to solid provisional ballots.

In North Texas, Kaufman County election officers despatched DPS a listing of 59 voters, data present, and an e-mail from Tandi Smith, the Kaufman County elections administrator, mentioned all “have sworn provisional affidavits attesting that they registered with DPS since moving to Kaufman County.”

Smith then underlined and bolded one sentence: “Your response is critical in determining if their ballot is counted.”

In an e-mail, Smith mentioned she didn’t have time to reply to particular questions from Votebeat about her inquiry.

Doreen Geiger of Tarrant County, who has been a volunteer deputy registrar for twenty years, advised Votebeat she typically advises new voters in opposition to registering to vote by means of DPS. “It’s just not very reliable,” Geiger mentioned. “Give it directly to the elections office.”

Some voters who registered at DPS mentioned they received to vote solely as a result of they stayed vigilant.

Sophie Sutherland, an Austin resident and native of England, obtained her American citizenship final 12 months after residing within the U.S. since 2005. However shortly earlier than her naturalization ceremony, her purse was stolen. She determined to attend till after the ceremony to exchange her license, so she may register to vote on the similar time.

At DPS, she stuffed all the things out and requested the clerk if she wanted to do anything. “No, that’s it. We’ve got it from here,” Sutherland remembers the clerk telling her.

However when she went to verify on her registration on-line on Feb. 5, the deadline to register for the March major, it wasn’t there. She rapidly known as a pal who’d been a volunteer deputy registrar who advised her to right away mail a brand new utility and guarantee it was postmarked that day.

That labored. However “most people are not going to be able to find the time or go to the bother,” she mentioned. “Some people simply can’t.”

DPS officers didn’t reply to particular questions on why some functions fail to make it to county election officers. However in an e-mail, the company mentioned the treatment is for election officers to contact DPS so the company can verify whether or not the individual certainly chosen “yes” on the voter registration utility query.

To assist stop errors, DPS prospects are requested to confirm their choices earlier than transactions are finalized, mentioned Sheridan Nolen, DPS’s press secretary. That occurs by way of a printout in individual and thru a affirmation web page on-line, Nolen mentioned.

A voter whose registration doesn’t come up on the voter rolls on the polls can solid a provisional poll. Greater than half the practically 39,000 provisional ballots solid within the state within the 2022 normal election have been as a result of voter not being on an eligible voter record, in response to knowledge tracked by the U.S. Election Help Fee, although it’s unclear what number of of these voters mentioned that they had tried unsuccessfully to register.

If the voter tells election officers that they registered at DPS, election officers are legally required to analyze. Typically, voters are improper — they assume they registered after they truly didn’t. But when election officers are capable of finding the finished utility, the voter’s provisional poll can then be counted. Days after Election Day, voters are notified by mail whether or not or not their provisional poll was counted.

The push for on-line registration stalls

Voters and a few election officers say there should be a greater method to verify registrations stick.

Charles Williams, 69, a retired railroad conductor, mailed his voter registration utility in June to the Travis County voter registration workplace. Two months later, Williams hadn’t acquired a affirmation.

His spouse, who has been an election employee in Travis County, inspired him to verify on it, and after he did, it took Williams months of ready, a number of calls, and repeat functions earlier than he was in a position to affirm that he was registered. “I want to make sure I am able to vote in November,” he mentioned.

His spouse, Carla Jackson-Williams was outraged by the obstacles.

“I think they should allow you to go ahead and submit that application online, and then follow up with a written one,” she mentioned. “At least then there is a record of someone who has applied, right? There’s a record and they can’t say it disappeared or that they don’t have it,” she mentioned.

Bruce Elfant, the Travis County tax assessor-collector and voter registrar, mentioned Williams’ expertise is why he has, for years, advocated for on-line voter registration.

“I don’t know why the state is not willing to bring voter registration into the 21st century,” mentioned Elfant, whose time period ends in December. “I don’t know what business would operate like this, but we’re operating this aspect of the state government like this, and it’s shameful.”

The one type of on-line voter registration in Texas is thru DPS, and the one individuals who can entry it are those that have already got a state ID or driver’s license and are updating their data by means of the company’s on-line portal.

That possibility grew to become obtainable solely three years in the past, after voting rights advocates sued the secretary of state and DPS, alleging they have been violating federal legislation by not offering Texans the choice to register to vote on-line whereas updating and renewing their identification. To settle the case, the state agreed to permit these voters to make use of the web portal in these circumstances.

However Beth Stevens, a voting rights lawyer who represented the plaintiffs, mentioned she is aware of it doesn’t all the time work.

Final 12 months, State Rep. John Bucy of Austin, a Democrat, proposed payments that will direct the Texas Secretary of State’s workplace to create an internet voter registration system.

The payments by no means received a listening to. He advised Votebeat he hasn’t gotten a transparent reply as to why. He plans to suggest it once more subsequent 12 months.

“This should have happened a long time ago,” Bucy mentioned. “The problem is, we’ve got political leaders that care about their power over voter access, and so they’ve stopped it. But we know this works.”

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott has but to publicly take a stance on on-line voter registration. His workplace didn’t reply to requests for remark.

The final time lawmakers held a listening to on the difficulty was in 2015. On the time, Republicans raised considerations about whether or not it could allow voter fraud and id theft. Supporters argued that the identical threat existed with the paper varieties, which ask voters for delicate figuring out data. These varieties are then dealt with by a number of individuals.

The shortage of a voter’s signature on an digital kind was one other concern. Supporters advised legislators on the time that different states have addressed that by requiring voters to have a state ID or driver’s license to be able to register electronically.

That’s now the case in Alabama, which carried out on-line voter registration in 2016. Residents there can register on-line, as soon as they’ve a state ID or driver’s license on file, mentioned former Alabama Secretary of State John Merrill, a Republican.

“We’ve never had a breach where any of our data had been corrupted, no improprieties, no concerns, no vulnerabilities have ever been exposed,” Merrill mentioned. “You have to remember all of that has to be added to the voter roll by the local registrar, who still has to verify identity and verify the voter is qualified. No one is automatically added to the rolls. There’s still a process that has to be followed.”

Earlier than Kentucky carried out on-line voter registration in 2016, the state relied on volunteers to return varieties to the county, as Texas does. Typically these varieties wouldn’t get turned in, mentioned former Kentucky Secretary of State Trey Grayson, a Republican. Election staff handled backlogs of functions, errors within the varieties, and typos.

However now, as soon as a Kentucky voter fills out the shape electronically, they obtain an e-mail affirmation, Grayson mentioned.

“The confirmation is essentially like your receipt. It shows that a transaction happened, and that’s comforting for the voter,” he mentioned. “It’s also a positive to the election administrator, because the worst thing that happens is when that voter comes out on election day and they’re not on the list.”

On-line voter registration saved the state tens of millions of {dollars}, led to extra correct voter rolls, and diminished backlogs and lengthy traces throughout elections, Grayson mentioned.

“There’s 43 states that have it,” Grayson mentioned. “Nobody’s repealed it. It’s not controversial in these states. It’s just the way it’s done.”

Natalia Contreras covers election administration and voting entry for Votebeat in partnership with the Texas Tribune. Contact Natalia at ncontreras@votebeat.org

• Examine your voter registration standing earlier than you vote at VoteTexas.gov.
• In the event you’ve registered to vote however your identify isn’t on the voter rolls on the polling place, ask to solid a provisional poll.
• By legislation, election officers are required to analyze why your identify just isn’t showing within the system and after Election Day will inform you whether or not your poll was counted.
• If this occurred to you, please contact us at group@votebeat.org

Disclosure: Texas A&M College and Texas Secretary of State have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partly by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.