Over the previous few years, Textio has printed an annual evaluation of knowledge about efficiency opinions. In 2022, we noticed overwhelming patterns of bias by race, gender, and age throughout greater than 25,000 opinions from 253 totally different organizations. Final yr, we noticed a transparent mathematical connection between suggestions high quality and worker retention. Individuals receiving low-quality written opinions are 63% extra prone to stop within the subsequent 12 months, even when the overview is constructive.
This yr’s information appears particularly on the suggestions obtained by a company’s high performers. Astonishingly, we discovered that top performers get extra suggestions than everybody else—but it surely’s additionally the bottom high quality. And high-performing ladies get the lowest-quality suggestions of all.
Excessive performers get extra suggestions…
On common, organizations acknowledge 5-15% of their workers as excessive performers. This small proportion of workers delivers an enormous chunk of the work. A complete research by Herman Aguinis and Ernest O’Boyle, Jr. from Indiana College discovered that excessive performers ship 400% extra productiveness than the common performer.
Retaining this group is crucial for organizational efficiency. Many corporations create particular profession applications and stretch alternatives for his or her highest performers. Textio’s annual information set that includes opinions from greater than 23,000 folks reveals that managers additionally give excessive performers essentially the most suggestions. On common, excessive performers get 1.5 instances extra suggestions than everybody else. That is true no matter worker race, gender, or different demographics.
…But it surely’s decrease in high quality
Excessive performers might obtain extra suggestions, but it surely’s notably decrease in high quality than everybody else’s. Excessive-quality suggestions focuses on somebody’s particular behaviors fairly than on their persona or different intangibles. It’s grounded in particular examples of labor deliverables, and it avoids commenting on folks’s mounted traits corresponding to their total intelligence. Lastly, honest suggestions is correct and never exaggerated.
This yr’s Textio information reveals that top performers obtain lower-quality suggestions in a number of dimensions. The suggestions for prime performers no matter demographics is extra prone to be based mostly on a cliché and consists of many extra exaggerations and overstatements.
Excessive performers’ suggestions additionally accommodates considerably extra commentary about folks’s mounted traits, each constructive and detrimental. For example, excessive performers are each extra prone to be complimented for his or her intelligence, and extra prone to be criticized for his or her abrasiveness.
Excessive-performing ladies get the bottom high quality suggestions of all
Ten years in the past, the information confirmed that high-performing ladies had been more likely to get suggestions about their personalities than their male friends had been. The ladies had been additionally extra prone to obtain explicitly detrimental fairly than constructive suggestions total.
Textio’s information from the final a number of experiences validates that these findings nonetheless apply a decade later. No matter efficiency degree, ladies get 22% extra suggestions about their personalities than everybody else. Ladies additionally get much less actionable suggestions, and what they do obtain accommodates fewer particular examples. That is very true for Black and Latina ladies. Black ladies particularly get 9 instances extra suggestions that’s not actionable than white males obtain.
Given this, it’s maybe unsurprising that the high-performing ladies on this yr’s research obtain lower-quality suggestions throughout the board. Their opinions are usually not simply lower-quality than the suggestions obtained by low and center performers, it’s also lower-quality than the suggestions obtained by high-performing males.
On common, 27% of the sentences in efficiency opinions written for prime performers comprise an occasion of problematic suggestions. However whenever you focus simply on the opinions written for high-performing ladies, 38% of the sentences comprise some occasion of problematic suggestions.
In different phrases, although all excessive performers get additional scrutiny in comparison with their friends, supervisor suggestions is particularly unhelpful for high-performing ladies. This poses an issue not only for equity, however for core organizational efficiency.
Final yr’s complete analysis confirmed that individuals who get low-quality efficiency opinions are more likely to stop their jobs inside a yr. We additionally noticed that the chance of somebody quitting will increase with every occasion of problematic suggestions obtained of their overview. This yr’s analysis reveals why organizations have had such a troublesome time retaining their high ladies.
If you happen to marvel why your high-performing ladies are quitting, have a look at their efficiency opinions.
Extra must-read commentary printed by Fortune:
The opinions expressed in Fortune.com commentary items are solely the views of their authors and don’t essentially replicate the opinions and beliefs of Fortune.
