Does Dade Phelan have the votes to maintain his job as Texas Home speaker? It is determined by the way you rely.

Join the We the Texans e-newsletter to obtain twice-monthly updates on our year-long initiative devoted to boosting civic engagement and chronicling how democracy is skilled in Texas.

---

The race for speaker of the Texas Home has narrowed, pitting Beaumont Republican Dade Phelan, who has held the gavel since 2021, towards Rep. David Cook dinner, R-Mansfield, who has emerged because the challenger designated by a gaggle disillusioned with Home management.

Earlier this month, throughout a non-public assembly of Republican Home members and nominees, 4 different speaker challengers dropped out and endorsed Cook dinner — and 48 attendees dedicated to supporting him over Phelan.

Assuming all 48 of these Republicans win their respective November elections and solid a vote for Home speaker in January, that will imply a majority of Home Republicans don’t assist Phelan.

Phelan says he has the votes to be reelected to a 3rd time period as speaker. Critics say he can’t win with out the assist of the Republican caucus. So what’s the deal?

There’s two key thresholds at play.

The primary is an important: With 150 members, it takes at the least 76 votes to develop into Home speaker.

The breakdown of the membership is 86 Republicans and 63 Democrats, plus one emptiness. However this stability might change barely this November.

The opposite notable threshold that comes into play is a vote that occurs earlier than the complete Home selects its speaker. Home Republicans, in keeping with their bylaws, will vote to endorse a candidate in a caucus election earlier than the session begins. Republicans are anticipated to assist that nominee as soon as the speaker vote involves the Home flooring — although it hasn’t at all times performed out that method.

Why are we speaking about subsequent yr’s Home speaker now?

Deciding on the Home speaker, who presides over the decrease chamber and has super management over what payments see the sunshine of day, can be one of many first motion gadgets of its members after they convene in January.

The speaker race usually takes off within the fall, however the quest to switch Phelan by his critics received began earlier than the final legislative session even ended.

Critics blamed Phelan for the Home’s impeachment of Lawyer Normal Ken Paxton and for the impasse between the Home and Senate on property taxes, the border and training. That included the Home’s final failure to go Gov. Greg Abbott’s college vouchers measure in November.

Paxton, Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick and former President Donald Trump endorsed Phelan’s main opponent in an try and oust the speaker, buoyed by thousands and thousands of {dollars} spent by organizations from outdoors his district and out of doors the state. Between the flanked assaults from Abbott’s and Paxton’s respective camps, 9 Republicans misplaced their primaries, and Phelan and 7 others had been compelled into main runoffs.

Quickly after, Phelan’s first speaker challenger launched his marketing campaign, accusing Phelan of “dysfunctional” management. Though Phelan survived his main runoff on the finish of Could, six of the seven others misplaced theirs, and Phelan picked up a second speaker challenger.

Regardless of Phelan’s victory, the incumbent members’ defeats and shut calls despatched the sign to many surviving Republicans that conservative grassroots activists had been fed up with the course of the Texas Home.

The 2 Republicans brazenly difficult Phelan marked the official begin to the race for speaker, however issues accelerated this month when three extra Republicans entered the race. Nevertheless, that group has since coalesced round Cook dinner.

Does David Cook dinner have the votes to be speaker?

Cook dinner’s declare to the gavel rests on his confidence that he can safe the Texas Home Republican Caucus endorsement.

The caucus bylaws name for the group to fulfill in December to decide on an “endorsed speaker candidate,” who should obtain the assist of at the least three-fifths of the caucus — a quantity that can fluctuate primarily based on the November election outcomes however is more likely to be within the 50s (If nothing modified, the quantity could be 52 members).

Cook dinner on Friday named 46 of his 48 supporters. The 46 named supporters are largely made up of the Republican Home members and nominees who signed a pledge in Could saying they’d not assist a speaker who would give committee chairmanships to Democrats, successfully aimed toward Phelan. Two signers of the Could letter aren’t named in Cook dinner’s record of supporters: nominees Pat Curry of Waco and Hillary Hickland of Belton. Two of Cook dinner’s supporters didn’t signal the Could letter: Rep. James Frank of Wichita Falls, who dropped his speaker problem to again Cook dinner, and Rep. Matt Shaheen of Plano, who instructed The Dallas Morning Information this summer season that he was supporting Phelan.

“The process of selecting a speaker of the House should always be done with a high standard of due diligence and should never be taken lightly. That is why I firmly believe Mr. Cook is the leader that Texas needs at this point in history,” Shaheen mentioned in an announcement. “David has been a trustworthy friend who will lead the Texas House with honor and integrity.”

Cook dinner’s record additionally contains two nominees, Don McLaughlin and Steve Kinard, who’re working in battleground districts at present represented by Democrats. Even when they flip each districts and no different seats change events, Cook dinner could be at the least 5 votes shy of securing the three-fifths assist of the caucus, assuming his supporters are proper concerning the present energy of his assist.

Nevertheless, that’s a lot nearer than Phelan is to getting assist from three-fifths of the caucus, and Cook dinner’s supporters imagine there’s a phase who would go away Phelan and assist Cook dinner within the title of social gathering unity.

Frank says Cook dinner is revered on each side of the aisle, calling him a considerate and engaged chief.

“We must put a fractured chamber back together so that we can efficiently and effectively lead our state, and most of the caucus believes that requires a change at the top,” Frank mentioned to the Tribune. “[Cook] has the support of a majority of our Republican colleagues, making him the current frontrunner to win the Republican caucus nomination and take this unified block of members to the floor.”

After profitable the caucus vote, Cook dinner must persuade the GOP Phelan loyalists to assist him on the ground. Frank says that pitch will embrace reminding Republicans of their widespread floor, nevertheless it might additionally embrace reminding them of the blowback they may face in the course of the 2026 main for voting towards the Republican majority.

Cook dinner wouldn’t should persuade each Republican, however he’d should persuade sufficient to get to 76. It’s unlikely his technique would contain courting Democrats to assist him, as he dedicated to blocking them from committee chairmanships.

Dade Phelan’s path to reelection

Phelan’s camp says they’re assured he has the votes.

“The path to the speakership is a matter of simple math,” Phelan’s spokeswoman Cait Wittman, mentioned to the Tribune. “As he stated last Friday, Speaker Phelan has the clear majority votes needed to be the speaker today and will have the clear majority support needed to become speaker again come January.”

Phelan didn’t present The Tribune with the record of members that assist him. Phelan’s record of Republican supporters is believed to incorporate key committee chairs and people dealing with the hardest reelection contests. Rep. Jared Patterson of Frisco reiterated his assist for Phelan after Cook dinner revealed his record of supporters.

“Results matter and the two most conservative sessions in the history of our great state didn’t happen until Dade Phelan became Speaker of the Texas House,” Patterson posted on social media. “As one of the top conservatives during the most conservative sessions we’ve ever seen, I’m proud to support his reelection as Speaker of the Texas House.”

Phelan has a pair paths to victory.

First, he might try to interrupt Cook dinner’s maintain on the Republican majority by convincing them that he’s the one candidate who might get to 76 votes on the Home flooring and win the endorsement of the caucus. Given the anti-Phelan sentiment throughout the social gathering, that is likely to be a troublesome path for him.

Phelan might additionally merely select to maneuver ahead together with his bid for the speakership with out the social gathering endorsement.

The Home guidelines don’t prohibit which members might be nominated for speaker, so as soon as the vote involves the ground, anybody might be put ahead for consideration.

Phelan has the assist of an inside circle of loyal GOP lieutenants, and he would possible have the assist of most, however not all, of the 60-plus Democrats. Phelan has been the one Republican speaker candidate this cycle who would proceed the longstanding apply of appointing Democrats to committee chairmanships as a part of a bipartisan management group.

The mixture of a minority of Republicans plus Democrats would possible get Phelan to 76 votes — however profitable with a majority of Democrats would incite the wrath of the far-right and inflame accusations that he’s indebted to the minority social gathering.

It could additionally require Republicans to violate the GOP caucus guidelines that decision on them to vote for the endorsed candidate on the Home flooring. Nevertheless, the caucus bylaws don’t have any provision for punishing members ought to they vote for an additional speaker candidate. Republican Reps. Nate Schatzline, Bryan Slaton and Tony Tinderholt voted final yr for Tinderholt on the Home flooring with no official repercussions.

Phelan’s camp didn’t reply to a query about whether or not he would nonetheless take his reelection bid to the Home flooring if he misplaced the endorsement of the GOP caucus.

What concerning the Democrats?

Phelan’s surest hearth path to retaining management depends on Democratic assist.

And that’s not essentially a certain factor.

Democrat Ana-María Rodríguez Ramos formally filed to develop into a speaker candidate earlier this month.

Though she doesn’t have a path to victory, her candidacy reveals that Democrats aren’t utterly united behind Phelan.

And Democrats could also be motivated to assist Phelan over Cook dinner as a result of it provides them a greater shot at retaining committee chairmanships, which give them some management over what payments will make it to the ground for a vote.

Although the anti-Phelan bloc has coalesced behind Cook dinner as their most popular candidate, there’s nonetheless time for others to enter the race. There might nonetheless be one other candidate higher positioned to cleanly get to 76 votes.

Texas legislation calls on the secretary of state to preside till the election of the Home speaker. Nevertheless, if the secretary of state is absent, the lawyer basic would preside, which might depart Paxton, Phelan’s No. 1 political rival, with the gavel as Phelan fights on the ground to retain his speakership.