Dustin Burrows walks a tightrope in search of Republican and Democratic assist for Texas Home speaker bid

Join The Temporary, The Texas Tribune’s day by day e-newsletter that retains readers on top of things on probably the most important Texas information.

---

5 years in the past, Rep. Dustin Burrows’ popularity sustained a significant blow amongst his Home colleagues.

The Lubbock Republican resigned as chair of the Home GOP Caucus after it was revealed that he and then-Speaker Dennis Bonnen tried to collude with a right-wing activist by offering a listing of 10 GOP members they believed must be focused by the activist’s political group within the upcoming main. The actions amounted to a surprising betrayal from Home leaders who had beforehand threatened penalties for any incumbents who campaigned in opposition to fellow members in future elections. One of many would-be targets, Rep. Drew Darby of San Angelo, mentioned it was time for the Home to “begin to heal and rebuild trust” — one thing that might solely occur if Burrows was “no longer in leadership.”

Bonnen retired. Burrows retreated from the highlight, however steadily labored behind the scenes regaining his standing within the chamber.

5 years later, Burrows finds himself on the middle of one other Republican Home management skirmish. But once more, he obtained there due to his proximity to a sitting Home speaker — this time Dade Phelan — who misplaced favor with a majority of GOP members. And as soon as once more he’s at odds with lots of the identical political powers that contributed to his authentic demise.

Now, Burrows is in search of the gavel for himself, rising because the chosen decide of multinational and reasonable GOP lawmakers — together with one-time critic Darby — after Phelan exited the race earlier this month.

His eleventh-hour speakership bid attracted rapid ire from the Home’s rightmost faction and their allies exterior the chamber. That contingent has vowed to censure and wage aggressive main challenges in opposition to any Home Republicans who don’t vote for his or her most well-liked candidate, Rep. David Prepare dinner, R-Mansfield. Prepare dinner turned the Home GOP Caucus’ speaker nominee after a few of Burrows’ supporters walked out of the caucus’ assembly final weekend.

In a declaration of political conflict, Burrows disregarded Prepare dinner’s endorsement and rapidly introduced that he had sufficient supporters to win the speakership in January when the complete chamber votes. He launched a listing of 76 supporters, simply sufficient to win, made up equally of Republicans and Democrats. Instantly, a couple of Republicans named on Burrows’ preliminary listing of supporters requested for his or her names to be eliminated.

Up to now, Burrows not has sufficient public supporters to win. However publicly he’s projecting confidence that he’ll. His path to victory seems to be counting on a coalition made up of extra Democrats than Republicans, resulting in a state of affairs the place his critics on the suitable are characterizing him as too liberal, whereas Democrats opposing him complain he’s too conservative. In a blow to Burrows, Gov. Greg Abbott final week urged members to again the candidate “chosen by a majority of Republicans in accordance with the Republican Caucus Rules,” although he didn’t point out Prepare dinner by identify.

Mark Jones, a political science professor at Rice College, mentioned Burrows’ elevation is partly a matter of fortuitous timing, as Phelan’s right-hand man on the time of his withdrawal from the speaker’s race.

“It’s sort of an issue of being in the right place at the right time, and being audacious enough to put yourself out there,” Jones mentioned. “One risk he takes is, if he crashes and burns, he’s going to be the guy who defected on the Republican Caucus and tried to conduct a coup with the support of Democrats.”

In an interview, Burrows mentioned the members backing him for speaker are “fighting to make sure we still have a deliberative body, the people’s House, where all members are going to have their voice heard [and] be able to represent their districts.”

“It’s bigger than one person,” Burrows mentioned. “I just happen to be the figurehead of it.”

Risking a full lack of energy

Among the many loudest voices in opposition to Burrows is Michael Quinn Sullivan, the activist whose 2019 assembly with Bonnen and Burrows led to the downfall of each. Sullivan was the chief of the now defunct far-right political group known as Empower Texans, that was funded by Tim Dunn, the Midland oilman who has led a years-long marketing campaign to wash alleged moderates from the celebration. Lots of the members opposing Burrows gained their seats with the backing of a political community financed by Dunn.

These efforts contributed to the ouster on this yr’s primaries of 15 Home GOP incumbents, a lot of them Phelan supporters who have been supplanted by challengers working on pledges to not solely depose the speaker and transfer the Home additional proper, but in addition strip energy from Burrows and the remainder of Phelan’s internal circle.

Lots of Burrows’ supporters, in the meantime, are members who’ve survived such main challenges and confronted years of verbal and political assaults from the rightmost wing of the celebration.

Greater than two dozen of these Republican members look like dug in in opposition to Prepare dinner, motivated to disclaim management of the Home to his supporters and their far-right political allies even when it means defying GOP caucus guidelines that require all Republicans to assist the group’s chosen candidate. A number of of Burrows’ supporters took to social media final week to underscore their assist and make the case for his conservative bona fides, together with his report of supporting GOP border safety measures and personal college vouchers.

Burrows discovered a tender touchdown 5 years in the past, after Sullivan launched a recording of the assembly wherein Burrows might be heard itemizing off the ten main targets in trade for giving Sullivan’s group media entry to the Home ground. The scandal was damaging sufficient to finish Bonnen’s speakership and spur Burrows’ resignation as Home GOP majority chief, however Burrows rapidly landed on his ft, touchdown Abbott’s endorsement — a key stamp of approval in a interval of turmoil — and profitable a key put up when Phelan ascended to the gavel: chair of the highly effective Calendars Committee, which controls which payments attain the ground for a vote and which stay bottled up.

Burrows argued that members are “looking for a known quantity” in Phelan’s successor, alluding to the 5 phrases he has served within the Home in comparison with Prepare dinner’s two. He additionally famous that a few of his assist is coming from members who “were very oppositional” to him across the time of the Bonnen scandal.

“I have gone from the highest of highs to the lowest of lows in that chamber,” Burrows mentioned. “I very much respect [the House], and I know the members know I care very deeply about it. And because I’ve had all those different experiences — some fantastic, some bad — they know the type of person and leader that I will be.”

This time, nevertheless, Burrows’ bid for speaker carries the danger of a full lack of energy, with the potential for being relegated to the background beneath a Prepare dinner-led Home. Regardless of how the speaker race performs out, Burrows might draw a severe main problem in 2026 backed by the monetary would possibly of Dunn and others who’ve spent hundreds of thousands focusing on Phelan and his allies.

Burrows has by no means confronted a aggressive main problem within the decade he has represented Home District 83, which incorporates about one-third of Lubbock and extends into a number of close by counties.

He flew largely beneath the radar in his first two phrases beneath Bonnen’s predecessor, former Speaker Joe Straus, earlier than ascending to manage of the tax-writing Home Methods and Means Committee in Bonnen’s lone time period main the Home. He additionally was tapped to chair a Home panel that investigated the mass taking pictures at Robb Elementary Faculty in Uvalde — a high-profile project throughout which he established a rapport with a number of the Democrats whose assist he’s now pursuing.

By means of his time within the Home, Burrows has usually been seen as a mainstream Republican who falls between probably the most conservative and reasonable ends of the spectrum. Texans for Fiscal Accountability, a bunch as soon as linked with Sullivan’s now-defunct Empower Texans group, put Burrows close to the center of all Home Republicans in its most up-to-date “fiscal responsibility index,” which scores lawmakers primarily based on their votes associated to “dimension and position of presidency.”

Prepare dinner’s supporters have solid Burrows as a RINO — “Republican in name only” — who can be beholden to his Democratic supporters if elected speaker. One Prepare dinner-supporting Republican, Rep.-elect Mitch Little of Lewisville, accused Burrows of orchestrating a “brazen attempt to circumvent the will of the voters” by going across the Home GOP Caucus.

Jones present in his personal ideological rating that Burrows was among the many most reasonable GOP members of the Home final yr, with a voting report farther to the left than all however 11 out of 84 complete Republicans.

“If we think about the Texas House as having sort of three main factions — Democrats, center to center-right Republicans, and the most conservative Republicans — it clearly places Burrows in that middle camp,” Jones mentioned of his ideological rankings, which analyzed greater than 1,500 contested votes taken by Home members throughout a number of legislative classes final yr.

In the identical evaluation, Prepare dinner was nearer to the ideological center of Home Republicans, suggesting he’s much more reasonable than probably the most conservative members who’re backing him, but nonetheless farther to the suitable than Burrows.

In any case, a few of Burrows’ supporters exterior the chamber have claimed he has a extra established historical past than Prepare dinner of delivering conservative wins — and, they declare, the speaker battle is extra about political management than the place both candidate stands on the ideological spectrum.

“This isn’t about policy; it’s about principle at this point. It’s about the fact that we’ve had more conservative victories than ever before, delivered at a very high frequency per session, yet the goalposts keep getting moved,” Zach Maxwell, a former GOP legislative staffer who has spoken out in opposition to the far-right efforts to purify the celebration, mentioned on social media. “Why? Solely because the self proclaimed watchdogs of the ‘grassroots’ don’t have a buddy as the top guy who will bend the knee and make them feel good.”

A balancing act

As Phelan’s proxy, Burrows is seen by most Democrats because the extra palatable choice between the 2 Republican speaker candidates — as evidenced by the 38 members of the minority celebration on Burrows’ preliminary listing of supporters. A type of members, state Rep. Josey Garcia of San Antonio, later mentioned she was not supporting anybody for speaker but. (No Democrats have publicly supported Prepare dinner.)

Burrows’ backing amongst Democrats is much from common. A gaggle of greater than 20 Democratic Home members have withheld their assist, with some citing his authorship of a sweeping new regulation, dubbed by opponents because the “Death Star bill,” aimed toward sapping the ability of native governments, significantly in Texas’ bluer city areas.

All this has left Burrows to carry out a fragile balancing act the place his efforts to woo Democrats over to his facet might result in extra Republican defections, and vice versa.

Prepare dinner, for his half, has vowed to finish the apply of appointing Democrats to chair any Home committees — a longstanding custom continued by Phelan and former GOP audio system, who’ve all granted Democrats a restricted variety of chairmanships. Prepare dinner has additionally pledged to make sure that GOP precedence payments attain the ground earlier than any Democratic measures.

Burrows mentioned he has not made any concessions to Democrats. On the problem of appointing Democratic committee chairs, he mentioned he would depart it to the members “to work that out amongst themselves” once they approve the Home guidelines subsequent session.

Moderately than making particular guarantees, Burrows mentioned he’s courting Democrats by leveraging relationships he has developed engaged on bipartisan points, and by signaling assist for Home guidelines “that allow the majority to rule but the minority to have their voice heard and respected.”

“And it doesn’t hurt that the other side has wanted significant rule changes to shut them out of the process completely,” Burrows mentioned of his efforts to court docket Democrats.

In an uphill bid to attraction to Democratic members final week, Prepare dinner’s allies have circulated a doc that calls up feedback from Bonnen and Burrows in the course of the 2019 assembly with Sullivan, wherein the 2 Republican lawmakers have been caught disparaging native leaders.

Throughout the assembly, Bonnen mentioned his aim was for “this to be the worst session in the history of the Legislature for cities and counties,” one thing he mentioned he informed any mayor or county choose “that was dumb ass enough to come meet with me.” Burrows chimed in that he hoped “the next session is even worse.”

Notably, Burrows’ invoice reining within the energy of cities and counties was enthusiastically supported by Abbott, who has warned that Texas is being “California-ized” by overregulation of native authorities. Abbott and Burrows have additionally been ideologically aligned for years on property tax aid, with the governor citing Burrows’ assist shepherding his precedence tax reform invoice via the Home when he endorsed Burrows in 2019; the 2 additionally lined up on the identical facet of a heavyweight conflict final yr over how lawmakers ought to present billions in property tax aid.

Abbott additionally just lately praised Burrows for penning an op-ed within the Lubbock Avalanche-Journal wherein he alleged that college boards round Texas have been elevating the prospect of closing colleges “to stoke outrage” close to the election. Within the op-ed, Burrows touted his full-throated assist for Abbott’s precedence of enacting a voucher-like schooling financial savings account program that might permit mother and father to make use of public cash to assist cowl their youngsters’s non-public college tuition.

And but, Abbott appeared to curtail Burrows’ path to the gavel final week when he broke his silence on the speaker’s race, voicing assist on social media for a candidate “chosen by a majority of Republicans in accordance with the Republican Caucus Rules.” Shortly after Abbott gave his tacit signal of assist for Prepare dinner, one of many GOP lawmakers who was listed on each candidates’ listing of supporters, state Rep. Charles Cunningham of Humble, confirmed to The Texas Tribune through a spokesperson that he was supporting Prepare dinner.

Prepare dinner’s supporters swiftly framed Abbott’s remark as a back-breaking growth for Burrows; Prepare dinner marketing consultant Elliott Griffin, for one, known as Abbott’s assertion “tectonic.” Abbott’s phrase is now thought to hold extra heft than ever after the governor flexed his political muscle on this yr’s primaries, spending hundreds of thousands to oust Republicans who defied him by opposing his voucher plan.

Others who’ve made clear they aren’t backing Burrows regardless of showing on his preliminary listing of supporters embrace Rep. Sam Harless of Spring and Rep.-elects Don McLaughlin of Uvalde and Paul Dyson of Bryan. With Garcia, the Democratic lawmaker, additionally asking off Burrows’ listing, the Lubbock Republican’s public assist seems to be at 71 members, down from the 76 he claimed on Saturday.

Renzo Downey contributed to this report.

Disclosure: Rice College has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no position within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full listing of them right here.