East Texans united to cease a water sale to Dallas suburbs — for now

Subscribe to The Y’all — a weekly dispatch in regards to the folks, locations and insurance policies defining Texas, produced by Texas Tribune journalists residing in communities throughout the state.

---

This text is a part of Operating Out, an occasional sequence about Texas’ water disaster. Learn extra tales in regards to the threats going through Texas’ water provide right here.

DAINGERFIELD — Mary Spearmon owes every thing to Lake O’ the Pines. It is the place she met the love of her life. It is the place they raised their household. It is the place her husband of 57 years, Sammie Ray, died.

“My children grew up on the lake,” Spearmon mentioned. “We spent weekends on the lake, swimming, fishing and picnicking. My husband would take me around the lake, and we would just ride and look at the beauty.”

That is why, one night in March, she stood with greater than 100 of her fellow East Texans and demanded the regional water utility not promote one drop of the majestic lake to North Texas.

“What about our children, our grandchildren, our great-grandchildren, and great-great-grandchildren?” Spearmon requested. “Not only mine, but everyone’s in here. What legacy are we leaving for them?”

For many of this 12 months, residents like Spearmon on this nook of northeast Texas have been on a singular mission to cease a possible sale of Lake O’ the Pines water to a cluster of North Texas cities. Dallas suburbs like Frisco and Forney, dominated by single-family houses, expansive buying facilities, and towering workplace buildings which have unfold far out from the city core, have pushed a lot of the expansion in North Texas, rising that area’s want for extra water.

Lake O’ the Pines is among the state’s 188 reservoirs constructed for consuming water. The lake’s virtually 18,700 acres of floor water stretch throughout 5 northeast Texas counties: Marion, Harrison, Upshur, Morris, and Camp.

Constructed within the Nineteen Fifties, deep within the thick pine forest close to the Louisiana border, the lake has supplied consuming water to seven cities surrounding the lake: Avinger, Daingerfield, Hughes Springs, Jefferson, Lone Star, Ore Metropolis and Pittsburg. Over the subsequent 70 years, Lake O’ the Pines grew to become a defining pressure within the area’s economic system and tradition. Boats recurrently dot the lake whereas guests solid strains for ​​bass, catfish and crappie.

Christopher Lepri, a Jefferson resident, mentioned promoting the water would end in a decline in tourism, development and property values.

“Lake O’ the Pines is East Texas’ lifeblood, and that lifeblood should never be for sale,” Lepri mentioned at one city corridor assembly. “If Lake O’ the Pines is drained or sold, there would be a decline in tourism, growth and property values.”

Information of the Northeast Texas Municipal Water District’s potential sale kicked off months of offended conferences, on-line hypothesis, and criticism of secrecy. By March, one official had resigned, and talks of a sale had paused. Nonetheless, that’s carried out little to assuage fears. The heated battle and lingering tensions portend what may very well be Texas’ future if lawmakers don’t act this spring, as they’ve promised, to unravel the state’s water disaster.

Speedy development like that within the sprawling Dallas suburbs, local weather change and decaying water infrastructure threaten the state’s water provide. Texas doesn’t have sufficient water to satisfy demand if the state is stricken with a historic drought, in response to the Texas Water Improvement Board, the state company tasked with managing Texas’ water provide.

East Texas is the most saturated a part of the state, making it a pure goal for thirsty areas. The thought of piping water from East Texas to gas development in one other area touched a nerve for a lot of residents, elevating the query of whether or not one space ought to bear the price of one other’s growth.

Lake O’ the Pines was created when the Ferrells Bridge Dam was constructed on Large Cypress Creek, an 86-mile-long river. Earlier than building, the Cypress ran freely to Caddo Lake, a 25,400-acre lake and wetland bifurcated on the Texas-Louisiana border.

After the dam went up, Caddo Lake, 30 miles west of Lake O’ the Pines, practically disappeared.

Within the early aughts, the Northeast Texas Municipal Water District, which manages Lake O’ the Pines, started voluntarily releasing water to Caddo. That call strengthened the truth that the destiny of Caddo Lake has been straight tied to Lake O’ the Pines.

So when in 2023, Laura-Ashley Overdyke, the chief director of the Caddo Lake Institute, noticed Wayne Owen, the chief director of the northeast water district, communicate at a convention in Denver, she paid consideration.

Later that day, Overdyke heard a Dallas-area utility director inform Owen: “Wayne, I’d love to buy your water, but you’ve already sold it to North Texas.”

Overdyke was shocked. No sale had been publicly mentioned.

“Was Caddo’s water going to be sold off to the highest bidder?” she recalled questioning. “Was East Texas a willing participant in her demise?”

Earlier than transferring to East Texas to assist handle Lake O’ the Pines, Owen was a water planner in Tarrant County, which incorporates Fort Price. He mentioned, in an interview with The Texas Tribune, he was employed partly to assist facilitate a sale of water to North Texas.

“There has been … interest from the water suppliers in the Dallas-Fort Worth area to secure additional water supply,” Owen mentioned. “And, ostensibly, water supply that is a surplus in the Cypress Basin.”

Overdyke returned to Shreveport and went to work, understanding what a possible sale would imply for Caddo. In late 2024, scientists decided Caddo Lake can be fantastic if water had been diverted away from East Texas about 70% of the time. However any greater than that and lake ranges may very well be lower by a foot.

“For a lake that shallow, it averages about five or six feet deep, losing another foot would be devastating,” Overdyke mentioned.

Two months later, the proposed water sale was publicly mentioned at a northeast water district board assembly. The doable sale was then delivered to the Jefferson Metropolis Council, which met the subsequent day.

“The local people saw it and they started calling me,” Overdyke mentioned. “I was terrified.”

A whole lot of East Texans took discover and went on a mission to avoid wasting each Lake O’ the Pines and Caddo.

Anytime a metropolis council or county commissioners met, they went. They drove alongside winding two-lane highways lined by 80-foot tall pine bushes to cities like Jefferson, inhabitants 1,875, and Daingerfield, inhabitants of about 2,500.

Greater than 400 folks attended a February city corridor on the Mims Hearth Station in Avinger hosted by state Rep. Jay Dean, a Longview Republican. Weeks later, greater than 100 folks stuffed the biggest courtroom on the Marion County Courthouse to inform county commissioners their considerations.

Water is the brand new oil, Jerry Thomas, a Jefferson resident, mentioned.

“We all grew up in East Texas and know people who sold rights to their oil and watched others get rich from it,” Thomas mentioned.

Others wrote letters to any elected official they might consider. They submitted opinion items to native newspapers overlaying the struggle, just like the Marion County Herald & Jefferson Jimplecute, the Marshall Information Messenger and the Longview Information-Journal.

Residents spoke at size in regards to the influence they believed this sale would have on the native economic system, ecology and tradition.

The lake, as a 2020 report from Texas A&M Forest Service put it, is significant to the timber business, the poultry business, dairies, cow/calf operations, and for irrigation. Annually, the report mentioned, boating and fishing — particularly for trophy bass, catfish and crappie — entice numerous guests. These actions usher in vital revenue for folks residing on its 144-mile shoreline.

The incensed East Texans had few particulars on how a lot water can be eliminated or how usually. In lieu of info, many painted an image of a pipe the dimensions of a prepare automobile draining the lake at an inconceivable velocity. They checked out different reservoirs utilized by North Texas cities and had been fearful.

The northeast water board — every member appointed by one of many seven cities they represented — did little to assuage these fears. They had been sure by a 2023 nondisclosure settlement signed by Owen to maintain particulars quiet. What little info was obtainable was usually launched by the North Texas utility.

That self-imposed silence solely made the unrest worse. The response of water board members at one metropolis council assembly stood out to Lone Star Mayor Brianna McClain.

“We had a full house, and on the front row there were three Northeast Texas Municipal Water District members,” McClain mentioned on the Daingerfield assembly. “One individual immediately rolled her eyes and sighed loudly.”

Sharilyn Parr, a Marion County resident, labored with many others to search out and disseminate no matter info they might.

“There’s a lot of misinformation out there,” Parr informed the Tribune after the Marion Commissioners Courtroom assembly. “And water, itself, is a complicated thing.”

In Texas, floor water — water in rivers and streams, lakes and reservoirs — is owned by the state. Nonetheless, the state points water rights to companies, just like the Northeast Texas Municipal Water District, to make use of or promote. The northeast utility has held the allow to water in Lake O’ the Pines since 1957.

The northeast water district is permitted to make use of 203,800 acre-feet of water per 12 months, in response to information supplied by the Caddo Lake Institute. That quantity is split into two allocations: 47,000 acre-feet per 12 months for member cities and 156,800 acre-feet of water per 12 months for the Northeast Texas Municipal Water District, which is bought to different East Texas cities equivalent to Longview.

In regular climate situations, the lake holds 241,363 acre-feet of water, in response to the Texas Water Improvement Board. In flood situations, which increase water ranges into the flood swimming pools, the lake can maintain as much as 842,100 acre-feet of water.

The North Texas water utility, which serves cities like Allen and Rockwall and was negotiating the acquisition or lease of water with Northeast Texas, needed 75,000 acre-feet, sufficient for 450,000 Texans a 12 months. A draft water plan for the area mentioned that water can be transported 91 miles by pipe to Lake Tawakoni, a reservoir about 48 miles east of Dallas.

Jenna Covington, govt director for North Texas Municipal Water District, informed the Tribune she believed the mission was a “win-win” — a technique to share a useful resource that will in any other case go untapped.

“They’ve got excess water that is valuable, and we want to properly compensate the folks in that area for the purchase of that water,” Covington mentioned.

No greenback determine was ever disclosed.

The sale of water rights has change into difficult and uncommon, whilst demand for water will increase, mentioned Gabriel Eckstein, a professor at Texas A&M College who makes a speciality of water legislation. A lot of the present offers are leases, which give patrons entry to water for a particular period of time however go away the unique allow holder in management.

That cash may very well be used to improve the northeast area’s water infrastructure. Officers mentioned these upgrades — projected at round $74 million — would enable the district to carry extra consuming water and for longer, cut back every day operational prices and assist hold present charges regular.

After the criticism arose with such ferocity, Owen, the northeast water district govt director seen by many because the mastermind of the sale, resigned in March.

Owen known as his tenure in East Texas a “career milestone.” He maintained he was following orders to execute a sale.

“I was just trying to do the best job I could do,” he mentioned in an April interview.

The Northeast Texas Municipal Water District board accepted his resignation at a gathering in Daingerfield and informed attendees they had been by no means severely contemplating promoting water from Lake O’ the Pines.

“If and when there is ever a proposed sale on the table that we think is worthy of consideration by the cities, we, being the district, are going to go to the cities,” mentioned Jimmy Cox, the board’s chair. “We’ll present that sale, explain it, review the pros and cons, answer any questions they may have. And then they will make the decision.”

The greater than 100 offended East Texans in attendance didn’t purchase it.

That’s when Spearmon informed the story of her household.

“If we sell our water to Dallas, what are we going to do? Are we going to move to Dallas to have water or purchase our water from Dallas?” Spearmon requested. “No. We don’t want to do that. No. We want our water. Please vote no.”

Sammie Ray would have beloved that she spoke up, although most likely would have informed her to be meaner, Spearmon mentioned later.

Kim Corridor, one other resident, steered that as a substitute of sending North Texas water, East Texas might ship people to repair North Texas’ growing older water infrastructure. Leaking pipes trigger cities to lose what water they do have.

“Were it not for the public outcry, your plans may have been consummated,” mentioned former Republican State Rep. David Simpson.

A number of known as for board members to resign with Owen.

Because the assembly ended, the board appointed Osiris Brantley, a lifelong East Texan and the water district’s chief monetary officer, as interim basic supervisor.

It was a small win. However the struggle isn’t over, East Texans mentioned.

“This is just the beginning,” mentioned Marion County Choose Leward LaFleur.

Final week, Dean, the state consultant who hosted a city corridor, posted on Fb that the risk was over.

“WE DID IT! WE SAVED OUR LAKES!” his put up mentioned.

“The North Texas Water District Board has negotiated a deal to get water from resources closer to them,” it went on. “And they have abandoned their proposal to buy the water rights to Lake O’ the Pines!”

A whole lot of his constituents favored the put up and shared it. Dozens of self-congratulating feedback adopted.

However any celebration gave the impression to be untimely, because the North Texas Municipal Water District countered in its personal assertion Friday.

“While we’re not currently in active negotiations with the Northeast Texas Municipal Water District regarding a water purchase from Lake O’ the Pines,” it mentioned, “we continue to believe a future agreement for the sale of water could make sense for North Texas and Northeast Texas.”

Disclosure: Fb and Texas A&M College have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partly by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full checklist of them right here.

---

Tickets are on sale now for the fifteenth annual Texas Tribune Pageant, Texas’ breakout concepts and politics occasion taking place Nov. 13–15 in downtown Austin. Get tickets earlier than Might 1 and save massive! TribFest 2025 is introduced by JPMorganChase.