This website collects cookies to deliver better user experience, you agree to the Privacy Policy.
Accept
Sign In
The Texas Reporter
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Texas
  • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Business
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Real Estate
  • Crypto & NFTs
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
    • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Books
    • Arts
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
Reading: Georgia’s citizen’s-arrest repeal not a path for states to follow
Share
The Texas ReporterThe Texas Reporter
Font ResizerAa
Search
  • Home
  • Trending
  • Texas
  • World
  • Politics
  • Opinion
  • Business
    • Business
    • Economy
    • Real Estate
  • Crypto & NFTs
  • Tech
  • Lifestyle
    • Lifestyle
    • Food
    • Travel
    • Fashion
    • Books
    • Arts
  • Health
  • Sports
  • Entertainment
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
© The Texas Reporter. All Rights Reserved.
Politics

Georgia’s citizen’s-arrest repeal not a path for states to follow

Editorial Board
Editorial Board Published June 30, 2021
Share
Georgia’s citizen’s-arrest repeal not a path for states to follow
SHARE

ANALYSIS/OPINION:

In February 2020, three White residents of Brunswick, Georgia, attempted what they claimed was a lawful citizen’s arrest of Ahmaud Arbery, a Black jogger they suspected of trespassing on a residential construction site. Armed with an assortment of guns, they chased Arbery down in their trucks, cut him off and fatally shot him in the ensuing confrontation.

The would-be arrestors now stand charged with murder. Their trial date is set for October.

Meanwhile, the public outcry over Arbery’s death brought the right of citizen’s arrest into the national spotlight. It has also brought legislative action. This May, a little over a year after the deadly encounter, Georgia officially repealed its citizen’s-arrest statute.

What should we make of this repeal?

In short, complete repeal works in Georgia, but it isn’t a path forward for other states.  

Citizen’s-arrest laws are deeply rooted in centuries-old Anglo-American concepts of law enforcement as a community responsibility. In a nation where most police departments employ fewer than 10 full-time officers, the ability of private citizens to detain criminals continues to play an important role in law enforcement and overall public safety.

While citizen’s-arrest laws are sometimes misused, these scenarios are rare. It is far more common that ordinary citizens act reasonably and responsibly to prevent actual criminals from fleeing until police can arrive.

Even so, many states maintain citizen’s-arrest statutes that would benefit from reform.

Undoubtedly, Georgia’s particular statute — confusing, poorly worded, and capable of justifying apparent acts of vigilantism — was among those in need of fixing.

Yet instead of reform, Georgia opted for straight repeal.

And while Georgia’s repeal of its distinctively awful citizen’s-arrest statute isn’t a total disaster, neither does it present a useful roadmap for other states looking to modernize their own citizen’s-arrest laws.

Repeal in Georgia was practicable only because, as its supporters repeatedly emphasized, repealing the citizen’s-arrest statute did not necessarily repeal citizen’s arrest in practice. Under other unique aspects of state law, residents independently maintain a right to detain criminals in a way that reasonably mirrors what they could do under a model citizen’s arrest statute.

Georgia courts have interpreted state law as protecting a broad right of self-defense that appears to permit private citizens to detain individuals for police custody in any situation where defensive force is justified. They may also use or threaten the use of deadly force to stop forcible felonies and apparently have a limited ability to pursue criminals in the immediate aftermath of forcible felonies.

Unfortunately, because these independent rights aren’t explicitly detailed in the state’s criminal code, laymen remain just as ill-equipped to understand which actions are or aren’t lawful as they were under the state’s now-repealed statute.

Moreover, it’s unclear how many other states, if any, maintain similarly broad rights of self-defense such that complete repeal of citizen’s-arrest statutes wouldn’t leave peaceable citizens without a means of preventing criminal assailants from fleeing the scene.

Instead of repeal, other states should look for reform.

That reform should focus on clarity, accessibility and reasonable limitations on the circumstances of arrest. Laws should emphasize and protect the primarily defensive nature of citizen’s arrests, with strict constraints placed on the ability of private individuals to actively seek out or pursue suspected criminals.

Clearer and modernized citizen’s-arrest statutes won’t prevent every conceivable abuse of the law any more than clearer self-defense statutes would prevent every case of questionable actions riding the line between lawful defensive force and murder.

But clarifying the lines between lawful citizen’s arrests and unlawful vigilantism is nonetheless in Americans’ best interests and would help minimize the likelihood of future confrontations like the one resulting in Ahmaud Arbery’s death.

• A legal fellow in The Heritage Foundation’s Meese Center for Legal and Judicial Studies, Amy Swearer is the author of a recent Legal Memorandum on citizen’s arrest.

Sign up for Daily Newsletters

TAGGED:Politics
Share This Article
Twitter Email Copy Link Print
Previous Article Brandon Blackwood Blows Up Brandon Blackwood Blows Up
Next Article ‘We are playing catch-up’: Biden meets with western governors about wildfires ‘We are playing catch-up’: Biden meets with western governors about wildfires

Editor's Pick

Sizzling Lady Summer time Begins within the Bathe—Right here’s Learn how to Prep Your Pores and skin

Sizzling Lady Summer time Begins within the Bathe—Right here’s Learn how to Prep Your Pores and skin

We might obtain a portion of gross sales if you buy a product by a hyperlink on this article. Most…

By Editorial Board 8 Min Read
Alpine’s Sizzling Hatch EV Has a Constructed-In, ‘Gran Turismo’ Model Driving Teacher

One other win over its Renault 5 sibling is a multi-link rear…

3 Min Read
Louis Vuitton Is Dropping a New Perfume As a result of It’s Sizzling | FashionBeans

We independently consider all beneficial services and products. Any services or products…

2 Min Read

Latest

“A Family’s Fight to Reclaim Their Legacy”

“A Family’s Fight to Reclaim Their Legacy”

Introduction: For generations, the Wright family has worked and lived…

July 9, 2025

AR Global Inc CEO Kason Roberts Donates to Support Kerrville Storm Victims, Mobilizes Team for Restoration Efforts

Kerrville, Texas — In the aftermath…

July 9, 2025

Bitcoin Tops $109,000 After Senate Passes Trump’s ‘Big Beautiful Bill’ – “The Defiant”

The crypto market posted modest good…

July 9, 2025

Two vital hazard alerts within the June employment report – Indignant Bear

Two vital hazard alerts within the…

July 9, 2025

Simone Biles Thirst Traps in Bikini Amidst Boob Job Hypothesis

Studying Time: 3 minutes Simone Biles…

July 9, 2025

You Might Also Like

Trump hasn’t delivered ‘no taxes on tips’ promise—however Democrats ought to
Politics

Trump hasn’t delivered ‘no taxes on tips’ promise—however Democrats ought to

In its explainer on President Donald Trump’s “no taxes on tips” provision in his “One Big, Beautiful Bill,” NPR used…

5 Min Read
Elon Musk’s obnoxious political ambitions are tanking Tesla
Politics

Elon Musk’s obnoxious political ambitions are tanking Tesla

Tesla traders reportedly aren’t thrilled about CEO Elon Musk’s plans to launch a political get together. Based on The Washington…

6 Min Read
Sign is again to hang-out the Trump workforce—this time concentrating on Marco Rubio
Politics

Sign is again to hang-out the Trump workforce—this time concentrating on Marco Rubio

There’s an impersonator of Secretary of State Marco Rubio on the free, and so they’re utilizing synthetic intelligence to focus…

4 Min Read
RFK Jr. is steering public well being companies off a cliff
Politics

RFK Jr. is steering public well being companies off a cliff

It’s tough to maintain monitor of all of the methods through which Well being and Human Providers Secretary Robert F.…

6 Min Read
The Texas Reporter

About Us

Welcome to The Texas Reporter, a newspaper based in Houston, Texas that covers a wide range of topics for our readers. At The Texas Reporter, we are dedicated to providing our readers with the latest news and information from around the world, with a focus on issues that are important to the people of Texas.

Company

  • About Us
  • Newsroom Policies & Standards
  • Diversity & Inclusion
  • Careers
  • Media & Community Relations
  • WP Creative Group
  • Accessibility Statement

Contact Us

  • Contact Us
  • Contact Customer Care
  • Advertise
  • Licensing & Syndication
  • Request a Correction
  • Contact the Newsroom
  • Send a News Tip
  • Report a Vulnerability

Term of Use

  • Digital Products Terms of Sale
  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Settings
  • Submissions & Discussion Policy
  • RSS Terms of Service
  • Ad Choices

© The Texas Reporter. All Rights Reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Lost your password?