Immigration is taking middle stage in Texas’ Senate race. Right here’s what Colin Allred, Ted Cruz’s data present.

Join the We the Texans e-newsletter to obtain twice-monthly updates on our year-long initiative devoted to boosting civic engagement and chronicling how democracy is skilled in Texas.

Not like many Texas Democrats earlier than him, U.S. Rep. Colin Allred needs to speak in regards to the border.

Specifically, he needs to speak about how U.S. Sen. Ted Cruz, who he’s difficult this November, helped spike main bipartisan border laws earlier this yr — a part of Allred’s broader effort to color Cruz as an obstructionist whose hardline stances have hindered long-overdue immigration reform.

On the similar time, Allred is attempting to outline his personal comparatively unknown immigration views earlier than Cruz can do it for him, operating advertisements that decision himself “tough” on the border and embracing a mixture of proposals bolstering border safety and increasing pathways to authorized standing.

However the notion that Allred is hard on the border is laughable to Cruz, who says his Democratic foe is attempting to have it each methods and displaying a newfound curiosity within the matter solely now that he’s operating for statewide workplace. Cruz, who can be making immigration the linchpin of his marketing campaign, stated Allred is papering over a voting report and previous feedback that present the Dallas Democrat extra aligned with President Joe Biden’s unpopular border insurance policies than he would have voters consider.

With three and half months left till Election Day, each candidates are campaigning on border and immigration points: Allred is operating marketing campaign advertisements that tout headlines about him breaking together with his get together to sentence Biden, whereas Cruz laced into the president’s insurance policies in a energetic speech on the Republican Nationwide Conference Tuesday, blaming Biden for a number of current high-profile murders allegedly dedicated by immigrants who entered the nation illegally. The border-centric campaigns are a nod to public opinion polls which have repeatedly proven Texas voters rating immigration and the border as their most urgent points — and voicing overwhelming disapproval of Biden’s method, as report numbers of migrants have tried to enter Texas from Mexico for many of his time period.

Cruz, requested in regards to the assaults on his alleged intransigence on the bipartisan immigration package deal, stated he opposed the invoice as a result of it was “terrible policy” that did not “actually secure the border.” He stated he’s additionally helped move much less seen however necessary border measures — like permitting real-time knowledge sharing between Border Patrol and the Coast Guard — and has seen his personal “commonsense” payments get shot down by Democrats. One instance, Cruz stated, is his proposal to require obligatory minimal jail sentences for these with an aggravated felony conviction who re-enter the nation illegally.

“Over the past decade I’ve repeatedly authored and introduced strong border legislation, and Democrats like Allred have repeatedly refused to agree to anything that would actually secure the border,” Cruz stated in an e mail to The Texas Tribune.

Allred disputed the concept that he has solely not too long ago made the border a precedence, pointing to his ties to the border metropolis of Brownsville, the place his mom is from and his grandfather labored as a U.S. Customs officer. He acknowledged that “too often, Democrats have failed to be serious” about responding to frame crises, although he additionally pointed the finger at Cruz and different Republicans for Congress’ long-running failure to move a serious immigration overhaul.

“One of my biggest frustrations with Sen. Cruz is that he’s had 12 years to try and enact any kind of reform — whether it’s comprehensive or even just targeted — to try and help us do something about what’s been happening at the border. And he has, every single time, refused,” Allred stated in an interview.

Even together with his extra proactive method, although, Allred faces an uphill climb shaking his get together’s model amongst Texas voters, who have routinely stated they belief Republicans over Democrats on border and immigration issues. Andrew Smith, a political science professor on the College of Texas Rio Grande Valley, stated Allred is strolling a tightrope.

“If he doesn’t go tough enough, if you will, on securing the border, he’s not going to get those centrist and moderate voters that are willing to vote against Cruz,” Smith stated. “But if he does get quote-unquote too tough, he risks alienating the younger, more progressive wing of the Democratic Party.”

Allred’s border report

Within the Democratic main earlier this yr, Allred’s border stance got here underneath hearth from the left over his vote for a GOP decision condemning Biden’s “open-borders policies.” Allred’s rival within the race, state Sen. Roland Gutierrez of San Antonio, blasted Allred for throwing Biden “under the bus … just for political expediency.”

On the time, Allred stated it was a tricky vote that he noticed as a technique to present he didn’t help the “status quo.” A spokesperson for Cruz’s marketing campaign known as the vote “cowardly flip-flopping” after Allred had “consistently voted with his party for reckless border policies that benefit the undocumented, while weakening our country and its borders.”

Allred stated he has made it clear when he helps Biden’s border insurance policies — like with final month’s govt order that halts asylum claims when unlawful crossings hit a sure level — and he has spoken out the place he disapproves. He stated his vote for the Republican border decision was a chief instance, displaying “I disagreed with what I thought was a much-delayed response to what had been an obvious crisis for some time.”

Cruz stated if Allred actually felt that method, he ought to have gotten behind Home Republicans’ wide-ranging border crackdown final yr.

The GOP border package deal handed the Home with none Democratic votes. Cruz known as it “the most comprehensive border security legislation in decades” and launched a model within the Senate, although Democrats within the higher chamber had already made clear it was lifeless on arrival.

The proposal would have restarted building on a border wall, restricted asylum eligibility, required migrants to attend out asylum claims in Mexico and stiffened penalties for overstaying visas. Democrats panned the invoice for focusing solely on harder enforcement and stated it was too draconian.

Allred stated whereas he would possibly help some features of the measure, the general package deal was an “unserious partisan messaging bill” that by no means had any likelihood to turn into legislation.

“It was only intended to be used by folks in an election like this to say, ‘well, you didn’t support this,’” he stated.

As an alternative, Allred helps a invoice penned by U.S. Rep. Veronica Escobar, D-El Paso, and Florida Republican Rep. Maria Salazar that features a mixture of security-minded options and insurance policies addressing authorized immigration and the standing of undocumented individuals within the U.S.

That package deal, which did not achieve traction within the GOP-controlled Home, would fund extra border personnel and surveillance expertise and require employers to finally use E-Confirm, the digital service that checks workers’ immigration standing. It additionally proposes increasing visa applications for non permanent and expert staff; granting some undocumented immigrants authorized standing in the event that they pay a price and move a felony background verify; and establishing “humanitarian campuses” at busy areas of the U.S.-Mexico border the place asylum seekers would quickly keep whereas their claims are processed.

“We cannot secure the border without fixing our legal immigration system,” Allred stated, arguing the disaster is fueled by “the fact that [the system] doesn’t work and that it’s so broken that folks feel like they have no legal way to come to the country.”

Sharon Navarro, a political science professor on the College of Texas at San Antonio, stated Allred is heading in the right direction strategically attempting to convey help for a bipartisan method, although she famous that voters usually tune out coverage specifics in campaigns dominated by sound bites.

“It’s a sound political strategy, but it’s very difficult, because right now all voters want to hear is, can we stop the border? Can you stop the flow of immigrants?” Navarro stated. “And so, short of that, I don’t think they’re convinced or want to hear the details.”

The Escobar-Salazar invoice additionally consists of funding for bodily boundaries alongside the border, an idea Allred backed in his first yr in Congress. However he additionally beforehand known as former President Donald Trump’s wall proposal “racist” and “ineffective,” feedback which have drawn flak from Cruz.

Allred stated bodily boundaries make “all the sense in the world” in sure spots and needs to be handled as “one component” of the nation’s border safety system. He contrasted that with Trump’s thought of constructing a wall “from sea to shining sea.”

“I’ve never supported, and won’t ever support, this idea that we need to have some kind of symbol that people are not welcome,” Allred stated of a full-fledged border wall.

Not too long ago, Cruz has been calling on Allred to speak in regards to the current killing of a 12-year-old Houston woman, Jocelyn Nungaray, who authorities say was murdered by two Venezuelan migrants who entered the nation illegally. The suspects had been apprehended by Border Patrol earlier this yr and launched into the nation to await immigration court docket proceedings, federal authorities stated; Cruz not too long ago filed laws geared toward holding migrants in custody if detention beds can be found.

In his emailed response, Cruz pointed to Nungaray’s demise for instance of how border insurance policies favored by Allred “allow monsters into our country who have assaulted and murdered Americans.” The senator’s marketing campaign has claimed there was a “drastic increase in crimes by illegal aliens,” and Cruz advised as a lot in his Tuesday conference speech, although a current research by the Cato Institute, a libertarian assume tank, discovered that migrants who entered the nation illegally are convicted of murder in Texas at decrease charges than native-born residents. There don’t look like any knowledge displaying a current uptick within the charge of violent crime amongst undocumented immigrants.

Requested about Nungaray’s homicide and Cruz’s competition that his most popular insurance policies had been guilty, Allred stated, “I just think Jocelyn’s murder was a tragedy, and I can’t think of anything more shameful than someone like Ted Cruz attempting to use that as a political attack.”

Cruz’s border report

On the similar time, Allred has sought to refocus consideration on Cruz’s border report, questioning whether or not the GOP senator’s hawkish stances have truly produced outcomes. He has notably emphasised Cruz’s objection to a bipartisan border package deal in February that included an array of border restrictions, however died after most Senate Republicans voted to dam it on the grounds that it was too lax. A variety of GOP senators got here out towards the invoice after Trump known as it an “open borders betrayal” that may profit Democrats politically.

Cruz was one of many first Republicans out of the gate blasting the proposal, which aimed to clamp down on asylum, restrict the president’s authority to confess individuals utilizing parole in sure instances and ship help to assist organizations and native governments pay for migrant providers.

Amongst his objections to the invoice, Cruz stated it could have “codified” so-called catch-and-release coverage, which he known as “the principal cause” of the uptick in crossings seen underneath Biden. He additionally stated the invoice would have “normalized” permitting 5,000 migrants to enter illegally on daily basis— referring to a provision requiring the shutdown of all border crossings between ports of entry if illegal crossings exceeded a each day common of 5,000 over every week, or reached 8,500 in a single day. Supporters had pitched it as a software to restrict unauthorized crossings, which had been exceeding 5,000 a day, however critics together with Cruz stated the bar was too excessive.

On the time, Cruz panned Senate Republican Chief Mitch McConnell for initially signaling help for the invoice. He informed Fox Information that McConnell had ensured “every single Democrat running for office” would say “gosh, I wanted to secure the border, but the mean old Republicans wouldn’t let us.” He additionally predicted, although, that voters “will not be fooled” by the try to supply “political cover” for Democrats.

Allred has seized on the “political cover” remark, framing it as an admission that Republicans opposed the invoice to disclaim Democrats a political win. A TV advert not too long ago launched by Allred’s marketing campaign assaults Cruz for opposing what was “actually a good plan backed by sheriffs and border officers.”

Nonetheless, Cruz stated he additionally disagreed with a provision within the invoice that may have instantly granted work permits to asylum seekers whereas they waited to have their asylum instances determined, so long as they first handed an preliminary screening. Cruz stated the change would have “incentivized greater illegal entry.”

Cruz stated he continues to observe the immigration imaginative and prescient he has lengthy espoused, summarized by 4 phrases: “legal—good; illegal—bad.” It’s the similar slogan Cruz has used whereas establishing his model as an aggressive fighter for powerful border restrictions, from his opposition to the bipartisan so-called Gang of Eight invoice early in his Senate time period to his immigration-fueled 2016 presidential bid, the place he sought to match Trump’s hardline stances.

“I support legal immigration, and want a pathway for hardworking, freedom-loving people to come legally into this land of opportunity,” Cruz stated. “But right now, cartels are exploiting our open border to make billions of dollars trafficking drugs and people across the border.”

Cruz outlined a handful of payments and amendments he has handed into legislation with help from Democrats, together with a measure offering the Coast Guard with a long-range radar system at its South Padre Island station. He additionally authored a invoice, signed into legislation by Biden, that directs the federal authorities to seek out higher methods to detect and fight an rising avenue drug known as xylazine, a kind of animal tranquilizer that officers have discovered blended in fentanyl smuggled throughout the border.

“I will say this: While the border issue is politically divisive, I’ve done everything I can to secure it and fight the drug epidemic in our country,” Cruz stated.

Disclosure: College of Texas at San Antonio has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partly by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full checklist of them right here.

Huge information: director and screenwriter Richard Linklater; NPR President and CEO Katherine Maher; U.S. Rep. Pete Aguilar, D-California; and Luci Baines Johnson will take the stage at The Texas Tribune Pageant, Sept. 5–7 in downtown Austin. Purchase tickets as we speak!