Rising prices and stagnant state funds pushed this West Texas college district to the monetary brink

Subscribe to The Y’all — a weekly dispatch in regards to the individuals, locations and insurance policies defining Texas, produced by Texas Tribune journalists residing in communities throughout the state.

---

ODESSA — When Superintendent Scott Muri joined Ector County Impartial College District, college students scored poorly on the state’s standardized take a look at. The state’s college ranking system gave the district a D the yr earlier than he was employed.

Muri, a veteran college administrator with a repute for working high-performing districts, mentioned fixing Ector County ISD wanted to start out with lecturers. The district was 350 lecturers quick. He used funds from a historic monetary enhance to public schooling authorized by Texas lawmakers in 2019 to introduce wage will increase, rent extra lecturers and prepare them.

His plan labored. Over the following 5 years, college students improved their grades. By 2022, the district’s ranking had gone as much as a B.

However the identical windfall that financed his technique has not saved up with inflation, a problem he and different educators throughout the state say has grow to be unimaginable to disregard. Ector County ISD faces a $12 million deficit in its price range for the 2024-25 college yr.

The district made cuts small and huge — from purchasing for cheaper web companies to closing down two colleges — however Muri refused to decrease spending on lecturers. Paying them is the district’s largest expense, he mentioned, however they’re additionally the individuals he credit for turning it round.

Ector County ISD isn’t the one district in Texas tapping into its financial savings and working within the pink. Like most Texans, the state’s greater than 1,000 college districts are feeling the pressure of rising prices resulting from inflation. In addition they face different monetary challenges, like the tip of federal COVID-19 pandemic aid funds subsequent month and a brand new state regulation authorized final yr requiring districts to pay for college security upgrades in response to the Uvalde capturing.

In the meantime, college leaders’ requires extra state cash haven’t been heeded. Final yr, lawmakers did not move a major funding improve as they fought over college vouchers, a program to make use of taxpayer cash to pay for personal schooling. Opponents within the Texas Home efficiently blocked voucher proposals, citing worries that such packages would siphon funding away from public colleges. However their efforts additionally meant colleges wouldn’t get any further funds: Gov. Greg Abbott had vowed to veto any proposal that didn’t embody vouchers.

For Muri, Ector County ISD’s monetary woes are an instance that, below present state funding ranges, giving youngsters a top quality schooling is changing into more and more unsustainable.

“Our state is not investing enough money in public education,” Muri mentioned. “That’s it.”

Turning a district round

Muri is a revered administrator who has spent greater than a decade serving because the highest-ranking college official in a number of districts. He started his profession as superintendent in North Carolina, the place he oversaw 28 colleges. He later moved to Spring Department ISD in Houston, which educates roughly 33,700 college students. There, he gained a nationwide award for his work upgrading know-how throughout the district.

Muri’s work at Ector County ISD led The Dallas Morning Information to call him a finalist for the newspaper’s 2019 Texan of the 12 months award, citing his management within the aftermath of a mass capturing in Odessa. In 2022, he gained a regional award for superintendent of the yr in West Texas. That yr, Abbott appointed Muri as vice chair of the State Board of Schooling, then reappointed him once more for a six-year time period.

Muri joined Ector County ISD, which serves about 33,500 college students, at a time when longstanding failures caught as much as it.

Low pay and morale had left the district with out sufficient lecturers to workers its lecture rooms. In consequence, most college students typically bought substitutes as an alternative of full-time lecturers, and kindergarteners attended college half of the day. Muri mentioned the influence of the district’s instructor scarcity mirrored in college students’ tutorial efficiency.

Muri, who has testified earlier than the Legislature on a number of events about instructor retention, pupil studying and schooling know-how, mentioned the district might solely escape its degraded situation by bolstering the standard of lecturers and principals. And for the final 5 years, he targeted on that activity.

Muri raised salaries from $45,000 to greater than $60,000 and promised annual raises to maintain up with the price of residing. The district partnered with native universities to launch apprenticeship packages for aspiring educators. He established a brand new paid program, the primary of its type within the nation, to coach lecturers who needed to grow to be college principals. Muri argued that efficient leaders start within the classroom.

The district additionally redesigned some instructing roles for a choose group of workers. These lecturers spend half the workday with college students and the opposite mentoring their friends. These lecturers make salaries of as much as six-figures.

Final yr, Muri helped the district persuade voters to approve debt to repair up the faculties after earlier failed makes an attempt.

Over time, issues at Ector County ISD bought higher. The variety of instructor vacancies has dropped to 60, which the district plans to fill this month. Each classroom is now staffed with no less than one full-time instructor, a few of whom get assist from a instructor’s aide.

Immediately, the kindergarteners’ studying degree surpasses the state common. Ector County ISD’s lecturers have earned nationwide accolades. Scholar scores within the state’s standardized take a look at improved. Commencement charges have gone up.

“Our kids have access to better human beings than they did five years ago, higher-quality teachers, and higher-quality leaders, and it’s made a remarkable difference,” Muri mentioned.

However this yr, the district’s earlier successes have been overshadowed by looming monetary hardships that can take a look at its potential to keep up its momentum.

College funding and inflation

A historic funding in public schooling that the Texas Legislature handed 5 years in the past helped pay for Muri’s initiatives.

In 2019, Abbott signed Home Invoice 3, which awarded $11.6 billion to public colleges — greater than the Legislature had ever authorized.

The regulation retooled the method the state makes use of to calculate how a lot cash to provide every college district. The method had not been up to date since 1991 and, in consequence, colleges in rural areas had been for years considerably underfunded in comparison with their wealthier counterparts.

The brand new system, which handed with uncommon unanimous assist, determines funding based mostly on a faculty’s common pupil attendance. Every college receives a base quantity per pupil and might get more cash if the varsity has youngsters with particular wants, like particular schooling college students or English learners.

College leaders say the method extra adequately captures the circumstances of every district however fails to account for modifications within the economic system.

Inflation in recent times has sharply elevated the price of items whereas making it tough for shoppers to maintain up with it. For colleges, the whole lot from educational supplies to development instruments prices greater than it did when Texas up to date its college funding method.

“The Legislature has been pretending that there’s been no inflation since 2019. It’s really hard to stick [to] a budget when your labor costs are up and your revenues aren’t,” mentioned Lori Taylor, a Texas A&M professor and division head who researches college finance.

Colleges directors final yr referred to as on lawmakers to extend public schooling funding to account for inflation however the heated, bitter battle over college vouchers curtailed any effort to spice up funds. State legislators additionally did not move all however one advice by a activity drive Abbott created to handle the state’s power instructor scarcity. The group had advisable pay raises and improved coaching.

Colleges and their advocates are getting ready to ask for more cash once more subsequent yr, when the Legislature reconvenes. Within the meantime, college leaders say it’s getting more durable to make ends meet.

A dire image for Ector County ISD

The most important share of Ector County ISD’s spending is for instructor pay and provides.

The district put aside $203 million for the 2024-2025 college yr to pay these prices — an quantity Muri mentioned will assist preserve his workers from going to work for different districts or the area’s profitable oil sector. He mentioned the district gained’t elevate lecturers’ pay to account for the price of residing this yr, because it did within the final 4, however will challenge a one-time bonus of three% of their wage.

“Compensation is one way that we ensure that we have great people, not the only way. But it is it is a significant way,” Muri mentioned. “If I wasn’t giving raises to my folks, especially in this area, they would find other opportunities — gas and oil pays a lot of money. So I don’t have a choice.”

College security bills have additionally gone up. Final yr, the Legislature handed a regulation requiring colleges to position armed personnel on each campus. Deborah Ottmers, Ector County ISD’s chief monetary officer, mentioned the wage and advantages for every of the 62 officers the district now employs price about $100,000. The district additionally has to pay for coaching, autos, dispatchers, administrative workers, gear and weapons. Altogether, its safety spending went as much as $8.2 million this college yr.

To fund its mandate, the Legislature authorized giving each college district a one-time fee of $15,000 per campus, plus $10 for each pupil yearly. For Ector County ISD, which means getting about $1 million from the state — some $7 million beneath what it must pay this yr.

The district’s property insurance coverage prices have risen steadily in the previous couple of years as properly. In 2019, Ector County ISD paid almost $2 million in property insurance coverage. This yr, Ottmers mentioned it paid $5 million.

“Our costs have gone up for … whatever we spend money on, just like it has in your household,” Ottmers mentioned.

Muri mentioned the district has minimize prices the place it might however he has no plans to chop instructor pay — he mentioned he would spend money on his lecturers once more if he was given a alternative. The district will attempt to stretch its price range to fill its vacant instructing positions. It eradicated different roles, Ottmers mentioned, the district might handle with out, together with clerical, upkeep, custodial and administrative workers.

However with out extra state assist, Muri mentioned, quickly there gained’t be rather more the district can do to remain afloat.

“I would hope that the Legislature continues to listen… to the needs of those of us in public schools, just as we commit to listening to what their hopes and dreams are for the state of Texas,” he mentioned.

---

The total program is now LIVE for the 2024 Texas Tribune Pageant, occurring Sept. 5–7 in downtown Austin. Discover this system that includes greater than 100 unforgettable conversations on matters protecting schooling, the economic system, Texas and nationwide politics, legal justice, the border, the 2024 elections and a lot extra. See the complete program.