Texas colleges acquired billions in federal pandemic reduction. It’s coming to an finish as the varsity yr begins.

Join The Temporary, The Texas Tribune’s every day publication that retains readers in control on probably the most important Texas information.

---

The $43 million infusion the Port Arthur Unbiased Faculty District acquired in federal COVID-19 pandemic reduction funds completed greater than Phyllis Geans might have ever imagined.

The cash allowed the district to improve antiquated heating, air flow and air-con programs. Lecturers earned retention stipends at a time when many had been leaving the occupation. College students acquired new band devices. An bold summer time program taught them about pictures, robots and skydiving.

“We were excited, really excited, because we started thinking about things that we knew were almost impossible,” mentioned Geans, Port Arthur ISD’s assistant superintendent of operations. “It was unreal.”

Districts like Port Arthur ISD, the place roughly 85% of scholars are economically deprived, acquired a stage of monetary assist they probably wouldn’t have acquired in any other case — they usually took benefit of it by investing in neighborhood well being, studying, infrastructure and security.

However the greater than $19 billion Texas colleges acquired in Elementary and Secondary Faculty Emergency Aid funds over the past 4 years will expire on Sept. 30, with a few exceptions.

The cash will go away at a time when Texas colleges are already struggling to maintain the lights on. Numerous districts are planning to enter the subsequent faculty yr with multimillion-dollar holes of their budgets as inflation has despatched prices hovering. The Texas Legislature failed final yr to approve a big increase to the bottom amount of cash each faculty receives per scholar — an quantity that hasn’t modified since 2019 — as lawmakers fought over whether or not to fund non-public schooling with taxpayer {dollars}.

Faculty directors say shedding the pandemic reduction funds not solely threatens the packages they paid for but in addition highlights how precarious their districts’ scenario has change into after years of clamoring for extra state funding.

“It’s not about making up ESSER, because we all knew that was one-time funding,” mentioned La Joya ISD Superintendent Marcey Sorensen. “I just would ask, without getting political whatsoever, that everybody just look in the mirror and say, OK, if we really haven’t provided additional funding since 2019, maybe it’s time that we just give school districts a little bit more of what they need, knowing that kids have different needs now.”

Congress established the ESSER program in 2020 to assist colleges tackle the devastating impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. In Texas, districts skilled important enrollment declines and the variety of burnt-out academics exiting the occupation skyrocketed. Years of academic beneficial properties unraveled as youngsters, dad and mom and academics struggled with faculty closures and the hurried transition to on-line studying.

District leaders say the federal pandemic reduction funds helped them tackle studying disruptions and supply further educational assist for college students.

“They helped us ride out the five years of no new funding from the state,” mentioned Ronald Wilson, Hearne ISD’s chief monetary officer.

Current research present the reduction funds helped colleges throughout the nation enhance take a look at scores. For districts the place most college students come from low-income households, the funds had been notably significant, and never only for teachers.

In Port Arthur ISD, the place most college students are Black and Hispanic and the four-year commencement charge is nicely under the state common, the Brilliance Academy summer time program took college students on an indoor skydiving journey, the place they realized about wind resistance, pace and velocity. The district created a program that paid highschool seniors to offer supplemental classroom instruction to elementary youngsters. Geans mentioned a number of the college students who participated in this system later expressed curiosity in pursuing a profession in instructing.

In the meantime, Paris ISD established revenue incentives for academics to mentor college students. Hearne ISD employed behavioral specialists and social employees to help college students and their households in the course of the pandemic. San Elizario ISD constructed areas for leisure actions like taking part in the piano and hosted household health, literacy and math occasions.

“I think we were more successful in growing the whole child, on the part where we’re growing young ladies and young men,” mentioned Jerrica Liggins, Paris ISD’s secondary schooling director and school transition coordinator. “We gave them things that they need to be successful in the next grade level or whether they were graduating and going out into the workforce. We gave them things that helped make them a better person.”

Faculties throughout the nation have confronted questions on how they’ve spent federal reduction funds. District officers who used them for issues like hiring extra workers for his or her central places of work, buying pool passes or renovating sports activities stadiums have acquired the harshest criticism.

Texas colleges will probably face related spending questions subsequent yr. Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick, who presides over the Texas Senate, just lately directed that chamber’s schooling committee to evaluation how public colleges spent the large inflow of federal COVID-19 reduction cash. The evaluation will probably deal with how districts used the funds to enhance scholar outcomes.

Standardized take a look at scores are one of many major methods wherein scholar achievement and development are measured within the state, and the identical is true for the way the usage of pandemic reduction funds has been evaluated in nationwide research.

In Texas, the pandemic prompted a dramatic decline in studying, with studying and math scores hit notably arduous. The consequences had been much more profound for college students who participated in on-line lessons. Math scores have but to rebound to pre-pandemic ranges.

How one can maintain colleges accountable for Texas college students’ educational efficiency has additionally been a contentious difficulty in recent times. Faculty districts have fought with the Texas Training Company over its letter grade accountability system, claiming current modifications would harm their scores. Faculty officers have argued that testing scores alone are usually not sufficient to measure faculty programs’ effectiveness.

What ESSER spending evaluations generally miss is the extent to which the reduction funds helped faculty districts keep alive, mentioned Amanda Brownson, deputy government director of the Texas Affiliation of Faculty Enterprise Officers.

The funds “helped them keep the doors open, helped them make sure staff were in classrooms ready to greet kids when they came back; it helped them not … collapse,” Brownson mentioned. “What we don’t have is the counterfactual: What shape would school districts be in right now if they had to manage the pandemic and had not had ESSER funding available?”

Sustaining the packages Texas colleges created with federal reduction funds will probably be tough with out them.

A current survey carried out by the TASBO discovered that out of 313 faculty districts throughout the state, practically 80% reported deficit budgets or an absence of sources as one in every of their high challenges. Ninety p.c of respondents mentioned they’ve lower than 1 / 4 of pandemic reduction funds remaining.

Gov. Greg Abbott has confronted sharp criticism from public faculty advocates for his unwillingness to assist standalone laws to considerably increase faculty funding.

Since final yr, Abbott has pushed for schooling financial savings accounts, which might permit households to make use of tax {dollars} to pay for his or her youngsters’s non-public schooling and different school-related bills. Opponents within the Texas Home, citing worries that such a program would siphon funds away from public colleges, efficiently blocked the measure. But it surely meant public colleges wouldn’t get the funding increase they wished: Abbott had mentioned he would veto any faculty funding proposal that didn’t embrace an schooling financial savings accounts program.

The governor has vowed to make an identical push when the Legislature reconvenes subsequent yr.

The uncertainty round state funding for public colleges has created a scenario the place faculty districts are spending extra time worrying about their monetary sustainability and fewer about what’s finest for college students, mentioned Monty Exter, governmental relations director of the Affiliation of Texas Skilled Educators.

However for low-income districts, cash difficulties are usually not unfamiliar. And so they plan to do what they’ve all the time finished: discover methods to offer for college students and households with their restricted sources.

Some faculty districts are encouraging their workers to be looking out for native grant alternatives. Others are considering of asking voters to extend the tax income going to colleges or assist faculty bonds. Few say they need to the Legislature for options.

”We’re taking as a lot of the funding points on ourselves and transferring ahead,” mentioned Hearne ISD Superintendent Adrian Johnson, including that he’s nonetheless hopeful that legislators will do extra to fund public colleges.

“But we’re not waiting on that to happen,” he mentioned.

Disclosure: Affiliation of Texas Skilled Educators and Texas Affiliation of Faculty Enterprise Officers (TASBO) have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no position within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.

---

The complete program is now LIVE for the 2024 Texas Tribune Competition, taking place Sept. 5–7 in downtown Austin. Discover this system that includes greater than 100 unforgettable conversations on matters protecting schooling, the financial system, Texas and nationwide politics, legal justice, the border, the 2024 elections and a lot extra. See the complete program.