Texas proposes first new guidelines for oilfield waste in 40 years

Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s day by day e-newsletter that retains readers up to the mark on probably the most important Texas information.

---

This story is printed in partnership with Inside Local weather Information, a nonprofit, impartial information group that covers local weather, vitality and the surroundings. Join the ICN e-newsletter right here.

Texas is inching nearer to adopting revised oil and gasoline waste administration guidelines for the primary time in 4 a long time.

The Railroad Fee of Texas introduced the draft rule at its Aug. 15 assembly and is now soliciting public remark. The rule regulates a spread of disposal websites for oil and gasoline drilling wastes, from pits dug subsequent to drilling rigs to giant business services managing poisonous waste from quite a few drillers. Waste streams that fall below the rule embrace drilling mud, sludge, cuttings and produced water.

The rule additionally goals to encourage extra recycling of the drilling wastewater, which could be 5 to eight occasions saltier than ocean water and, like different oilfield waste, is commonly laced with fracking chemical compounds, hazardous compounds reminiscent of arsenic, benzene and toluene.

The present waste rule was adopted in 1984, lengthy earlier than fracking revolutionized the oil and gasoline business. Fracking has elevated the quantity of oilfield waste and altered its composition. In Texas, waste pits have been linked to not less than six instances of groundwater contamination and tons of of violations of state guidelines.

Whereas the necessity to modernize the Railroad Fee’s guidelines is evident, the method has proved contentious. A activity pressure with members of the oil business and consultants met for 2 years to supply suggestions earlier than the Railroad Fee launched a casual draft to the general public in October 2023. That spherical of public feedback knowledgeable the up to date draft launched final month.

Fee Shift, a nonprofit group centered on reforming oil and gasoline oversight in Texas, applauded some provisions of the most recent draft, reminiscent of requiring operators to register waste pits with regulators. However the group warned that the proposal doesn’t present sufficient protections for groundwater.

Karr Ingham, president of the Texas Alliance of Vitality Producers, mentioned his group raised issues that provisions within the casual draft could be “unworkable” and too expensive for smaller impartial oil and gasoline firms.

“I believe a number of the changes that were made do address those concerns,” Ingham mentioned in an interview. “Yes, we’re much more comfortable with the current draft than that initial draft.”

The company is accepting written feedback till Sept. 30. The Railroad Fee proposes that the brand new regulation, which might substitute Statewide Rule 8, go into impact July 1, 2025.

“The proposed rules include a combination of strategies to protect groundwater from pollution, including engineering and design controls, groundwater monitoring, and closure standards,” Railroad Fee spokesperson Patty Ramon mentioned in an e-mail. “In addition, the design and operational standards become more strict as waste volume increases, and also considers factors such as time in the ground, and proximity to groundwater.”

Rule covers a number of oil and gasoline waste streams

Whereas drilling an oil or gasoline properly, oily waste, generally known as mud and cuttings, return to the floor. The operator digs an earthen pit alongside the rig to get rid of this waste. The pit stays open whereas the properly is drilled after which closed as soon as the properly is full, completely burying the waste underground.

When these pits meet sure Railroad Fee necessities, they’re mechanically permitted. These are generally known as licensed pits or reserve pits. Different varieties of business waste pits require a person allow below the draft rule.

The draft rule solely requires liners in reserve pits when groundwater is inside 50 toes of the underside of the pit. These pits can’t be in a 100-year floodplain however in any other case haven’t any setback necessities from homes and water wells. There isn’t a restrict on how shut the underside of the reserve pit could be to the underlying groundwater and no groundwater monitoring required. Nevertheless, for the primary time, operators might be required to register the situation of their reserve pits with the Railroad Fee.

Industrial pits have extra stringent necessities for liners, groundwater monitoring and setbacks from water wells within the draft rule.

Fracking has elevated the quantity of drilling waste, in keeping with regulation agency Baker Botts. The contents of the waste have additionally modified. Whereas operators initially used water-based drilling mud, many now use oil-based mud to drill horizontal wells for fracking. The cuttings that come to the floor can comprise diesel gas and different chemical compounds. Drilling waste, regardless of containing dangerous chemical compounds, is essentially exempt from federal rules for hazardous waste below the Useful resource Conservation and Restoration Act.

A separate part of the draft rule covers business services that deal with waste from drilling firms. The rule additionally governs business recycling services that course of the waste for reuse, and produced water recycling services.

Oil and gasoline firms will not be required to report the quantity of produced water generated within the state. However a 2022 report estimated that within the Permian Basin alone, 3.9 billion barrels, or greater than 168 billion gallons, of produced water is generated yearly.

Whereas the draft rule imposes stricter necessities than the preexisting rule, it falls wanting how different states regulate drilling waste. In North Dakota, for instance, open pits for liquid waste—together with drilling mud and produced water—are prohibited besides below particular circumstances with the regulator’s approval. New Mexico up to date its waste guidelines in 2008 and banned unlined pits altogether.

Drilling waste poses groundwater menace

Virginia Palacios noticed firsthand the impacts of oilfield waste when the shale increase took off in her hometown of Laredo.

On the Texas Groundwater Summit in San Antonio in August, Palacios, now government director of Fee Shift, remembered open-top vehicles sloshing drilling waste onto the roads in Laredo. She recounted seeing a waste pit at her household’s ranch that had an oily sheen despite the fact that the corporate assured them it contained solely water.

Most landowners throughout Texas don’t personal the minerals below their land. The oil and gasoline firms that maintain these mineral rights enter surface-use agreements with the landowners. These leases can embrace provisions for waste pits.

“We can’t rely on mineral owners to just get a good lease every time,” Palacios mentioned on the summit. “We’ve got to have good rules that apply across the board everywhere, so that we can ensure that groundwater is safe.”

Palacios is anxious that the draft doesn’t require operators to inform landowners after they dig licensed pits on their land.

“We need to do better by the landowners to let them know what is going to happen and to allow them to give informed advice,” Palacios mentioned.

Pits that aren’t correctly constructed or leach into the soil can contaminate groundwater. In accordance with the fee’s on-line database, the company issued 712 violations of water contamination guidelines since 2015. The fee didn’t present clarification about what number of of those violations occurred at waste pits. The fee has on report six lively instances of groundwater contamination brought on by waste pits and one case brought on by a business waste facility, in keeping with the state’s groundwater safety report.

Along with nonprofit organizations, some firms have doubts concerning the rule. Gabriel Rio, CEO of the waste administration agency Milestone Environmental Companies, informed the Midland Reporter-Telegram that the draft rule will not be adequate to guard groundwater. “This very much falls short of what the industry is already doing,” he mentioned.

Milestone Environmental Companies declined to remark for this story.

Oil and gasoline business supplied early suggestions

Jim Wright constructed on his profession in oilfield waste administration to win a seat on the Railroad Fee in 2020. Updating the waste rule was considered one of his priorities as commissioner. His workers fashioned a regulatory activity pressure to supply suggestions for a revised rule.

The Railroad Fee printed the casual draft after receiving this business suggestions. In earlier interviews, Wright has defended this course of and denied that his function within the business biased the rulemaking course of. Wright’s workers didn’t reply to a request for remark.

Fee Shift’s Palacios mentioned she is anxious that the waste administration firms topic to the rule had personal conferences with regulators earlier than the Railroad Fee shared the casual draft with the general public.

A number of waste administration professionals backed the protecting measures throughout the casual remark interval. Landowners and residents additionally submitted feedback in help of the brand new rules.

In the meantime, feedback from quite a few oil and gasoline operators pushed again on stricter necessities for reserve pits. The Texas Alliance of Vitality Producers sought an exception for liner and groundwater monitoring necessities for reserve pits which are open for lower than 18 months earlier than the waste is buried.

Ingham, the Alliance president, mentioned the group had additional conferences with RRC workers and commissioners following the casual remark interval. (Palacios confirmed that Fee Shift was additionally capable of meet with company workers).

Ingham mentioned that these conferences permit business to supply data that RRC workers might not have at their disposal. “They are willing to take those meetings and listen to us. This is not remotely uncommon,” he mentioned.

The newest draft rule consists of an possibility for operators to request exceptions to necessities for reserve pits.

Judy Stark, president of the Panhandle Producers & Royalty House owners Affiliation, mentioned in an interview {that a} “one size fits all rule” doesn’t make sense for her area.

Stark mentioned that notifying landowners of the areas of pits might create expensive delays for drillers. “You can’t wait if somebody is on vacation or something like that, with a $100,000 a day rig out there,” she mentioned.

“They used common sense on the draft,” Stark mentioned. “It’s still in its draft stage so I can’t say where it’s going to end up.”

Residents really feel impacts of waste services

Not everybody feels their issues have been heard within the rulemaking course of.

Tara Jones lives a couple of mile from the Blackhorn Environmental Companies stationary waste facility in Orange Grove. When odors from the power permeated Jones’ residence, she requested regulators to analyze.

She appealed to the Texas Fee on Environmental High quality, which regulates air emissions from stationary services, together with the Railroad Fee and her elected officers. She mentioned stationary waste services influence folks far past their fence traces.

“I am one mile away and there’s only one property owner between us,” she mentioned. “But when it comes to stuff in the air, it doesn’t really matter.”

Jones is skeptical that the Railroad Fee takes public feedback into consideration.

“I feel if you kick and scream loud enough, sometimes they do,” she mentioned. “But will it change their mind? I don’t know. I don’t really think so.”

In response to a query about how the Railroad Fee engages landowners and individuals who stay close to stationary waste services, the company spokesperson mentioned solely that they use “various sources of information and expertise,” together with public feedback.

“As with any proposed rule, staff will review and incorporate comments,” Ramon mentioned.

Palacios mentioned that the Railroad Fee ought to maintain public hearings close to waste services, not solely in Austin. She identified that Reeves County within the Permian Basin, which has probably the most business waste pits within the state, is a seven-hour drive from Austin.

Fee Shift is urging the Railroad Fee to increase the general public remark interval on the greater than 300-page draft doc.

“This is a massive overhaul of extremely important groundwater protection rules,” she mentioned. “We’re asking the commission to extend the comment period to 90 days to allow the public to meaningfully participate in this rulemaking.”

Requested whether or not the fee is contemplating extending the remark interval or holding conferences outdoors Austin, the company spokesperson didn’t reply.

Disclosure: Texas Alliance of Vitality Producers has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full checklist of them right here.

---

As The Texas Tribune’s signature occasion of the 12 months, The Texas Tribune Competition brings Texans nearer to politics, coverage and the day’s information from Texas and past. Browse on-demand recordings and compensate for the largest headlines from Competition occasions on the Tribune’s Competition information web page.