“Water is the new oil” as Texas cities sq. off over aquifer pipeline plans

Join The Temporary, The Texas Tribune’s day by day publication that retains readers up to the mark on essentially the most important Texas information.

---

This story is revealed in partnership with Inside Local weather Information, a nonprofit, unbiased information group that covers local weather, vitality and the atmosphere. Join the ICN publication right here.

In Central Texas, a bitter battle over a $1 billion water mission presents a preview of the long run for a lot of the state as many years of speedy development pushes previous the native limits of its most important pure useful resource.

On one aspect: Georgetown, the fastest-growing metropolis in America for 3 years straight, which in 2023 signed a contract with an investor-funded enterprise to shortly start importing huge volumes of water from the Simsboro Formation of the Carrizo Wilcox Aquifer, 80 miles to the east.

On the opposite aspect: the cities atop the Simsboro that depend on its water. Bryan, School Station and the Texas A&M College System, a metro space with nearly 300,000 folks, have sued the developer to cease the mission. A trial is about for the primary week of Might.

“We’re going to fight this thing until the end,” stated Bobby Gutierrez, the mayor of Bryan. “It effectively drains the water source of the cities.”

The pump and pipeline mission to Georgetown, developed by California-based Upwell Water, is the biggest of at the least a half dozen related tasks just lately accomplished, underneath development or proposed to carry rural Carrizo Wilcox aquifer water into the booming city hall that follows Interstate 35 via Central Texas.

It could ultimately pump as much as 89 million gallons per day, thrice the utilization of the town of Bryan.

“That basically stops all the economic development we have,” Gutierrez stated. “We’re talking about our survival.”

The battle over the Upwell mission might nicely be a prelude for the broader battles to come back as cities throughout Texas outgrow their water provides. Lawmakers within the state Capitol are pushing to avert a broad shortage disaster with funding to desalinate seawater, purify salty groundwater and deal with oilfield wastewater so as to add to the availability. However all of those options stay years from realization. Within the close to time period, solely import tasks from freshwater aquifers will proceed to fulfill the rising water calls for of thirsty Texas cities.

Regulation of such tasks falls to a patchwork of small, rural companies referred to as groundwater conservation districts, which could not be totally outfitted or empowered to handle plans for competing regional water wants that may have an effect on complete cities for generations to come back.

Texas regulation presents restricted readability, typically preferring a landowner’s proper to pump their very own groundwater over laws on personal property. Regardless of fierce denunciations of the Upwell mission from close by metropolis leaders, nobody has alleged that its builders have damaged any legal guidelines.

“We’re following the rules. Why are we being vilified?” stated David Lynch, a managing companion at Core Capital funding agency in Houston and a companion within the Upwell mission. “I think they feel uncomfortable about what’s coming and their reaction is to make us go away.”

In any case, he’s not the one one doing this. 5 years in the past, San Antonio began pumping as much as 49 million gallons per day via a 140-mile pipeline from the Carrizo Wilcox Aquifer. One other pipeline was accomplished final yr and can quickly start pumping to the town of Taylor and the brand new Samsung microchip manufacturing advanced there. One other, scheduled for completion this yr, will take water into the cities of Buda and Kyle.

After the lawsuit delayed the Upwell mission’s tight timeline, Georgetown commissioned two different pipeline tasks from the identical aquifer.

“People are starting to pay enough for water to make these sorts of projects work,” Lynch stated, driving his black Ford Tremendous Obligation Platinum truck down the filth roads of Upwell’s 9,000-acre farm property and nicely area in Robertson County. “There’s no cheap water left in Texas.”

In the midst of all that is the little Brazos Valley Groundwater Conservation District, based mostly within the small city of Hearne and in addition a defendant, alongside Upwell, within the lawsuit.

District supervisor Alan Day feels for the cities of Bryan and School Station. To an extent, he stated, they’re proper. The extra pumping from the aquifer, the earlier everybody will attain situations of shortage, although he doesn’t suppose it is going to occur as shortly as metropolis leaders say.

On the identical time, he stated, “Bryan can’t claim the water.” Groundwater is a personal property proper in Texas as sacred as every other. Everyone seems to be allowed to pump no matter their land produces.

“Water is the new oil,” stated Day, a former ranch supervisor of 27 years. “They have a commodity that can be sold and they have every right to sell it.”

At the moment, he stated, he has no authority to cease landowners from pumping so long as they fulfill the necessities of the allowing course of, which Upwell did. Even when he might do it, Day chuckled on the notion that state leaders would let his tiny workplace put the brakes on growth alongside the I-35 hall, residence to manufacturing campuses of Tesla, Samsung and Apple, and workplaces of Amazon, Meta and Google, in addition to one of many nation’s largest clusters of information facilities and its quickest rising cities.

Nonetheless, Day stated, there’ll come a day when that adjustments. The legal guidelines for his district, like all others in Texas, specify a threshold at which new guidelines kick in. It’s referred to as the “desired future condition,” or DFC, a degree under which the district will not be keen to go. Once they get there, everybody will face restrictions on pumping and the times of groundwater abundance shall be over for the Simsboro portion of the aquifer. To this point, no district in Texas has hit its DFC.

Day stated he’s solely following the principles. He’ll honor the property rights of landowners who need to pump, and after they hit the DFC, he’ll implement restrictions district-wide.

“What does that do to the growth of Bryan and College Station and Texas A&M and anyone else who is depending on Simsboro?” Day requested. “It stops it.”

The Texas miracle

This example follows a technology of steep development and growth that state leaders have dubbed the “Texas Miracle.” The inhabitants of Williamson County, seated in Georgetown, 28 miles north of Austin, doubled in 17 years to 700,000 folks whereas its median family revenue elevated by greater than 90%. Neighboring international locations share related tales, the place sprawling subdivisions and shimmering tech campuses now cowl former ranchlands.

Georgetown wants so as to add tens of millions of gallons per day to its water provide throughout the subsequent a number of years. When it signed the pipeline contract in 2023 that stipulated deliveries starting in 2030, it was performing on a a lot tighter timeline than many years which might be sometimes thought of for giant scale water planning.

“Based on hyper growth that we’ve seen in our water territory, we’ve seen the need for higher levels of contracted water sooner than we originally anticipated,” stated metropolis supervisor David Morgan.

Many of the new water will serve new residential areas, he stated, and shall be used primarily to irrigate lawns and different neighborhood landscaping. Williamson County can also be courting a cluster of 5 massive information facilities that it expects would carry one other 100,000 folks to the county.

However what if Bryan, and the cities of the Brazos Valley, need information facilities, too? The area is at the moment pursuing bold alternatives in semiconductors, nuclear vitality, aerospace, protection and life sciences, stated Susan Davenport, president of the Better Brazos Partnership, an financial growth group.

“These sectors, along with the growing workforce and families who support them, are directly dependent on access to our local water resources,” she stated.

Gold rush on water

Though many main tasks importing groundwater into Central Texas are simply now being realized, the plans have been within the works for many years, based on Michelle Gangnes, a retired finance lawyer and co-founder of the Simsboro Aquifer Water Protection Fund.

In 1998 Gangnes moved from Austin to rural Lee County. That very same yr, San Antonio, 140 miles away, introduced plans to import 49 million gallons per day from wells in Lee County on the location of an outdated Alcoa aluminum smelter. A chronic battle ensued and the mission was by no means realized, however many others would observe.

“That’s what started the whole gold rush on water,” Gangnes stated. “It resulted in all these groundwater districts being formed, trying to resist the water rush on the Simsboro.”

The groundwater districts have been fashioned by an act of the Texas legislature in 2001. However, when the time got here to make groundwater guidelines, highly effective pursuits saved them free, based on Ken Kramer, who beforehand directed the Texas workplace of the Sierra Membership for twenty-four years. Chief amongst them was T. Boone Pickens, the enduring Texas oilman who additionally needed to export groundwater from his land holdings within the Panhandle.

“There was heavy lobbying by groundwater exporters to make sure that groundwater districts could not stop exports,” Kramer stated. “Groundwater then became more of the target for moving water to growing areas and populations.”

Beneath a precept in Texas referred to as the “right of capture,” landowners are allowed to pump from their land no matter they’re able to. Adjustments made to the Texas Water Code in 2001 stipulated that withdrawals are allowed as long as they don’t have an effect on different allow holders “unreasonably,” which lacks a agency authorized definition. That leaves tons as much as interpretation for the groundwater districts of Texas.

“They live in a difficult world where it’s unclear exactly what their power is to tell somebody no,” stated Robert Mace, government director of the Meadows Middle for Water and the Setting at Texas State College. “If you tell somebody no you’re almost guaranteed to get sued.”

In recent times, a number of main pipeline tasks into Central Texas got here on-line. San Antonio ultimately bought its Carrizo Wilcox Aquifer water via a 6-foot-wide, 140-mile lengthy Vista Ridge pipeline which started drawing water from Burleson County in 2020, inflicting ranges in neighboring landowners’ wells to plummet.

The outdated Alcoa wells in Burleson County have been additionally put to make use of. A developer referred to as Xebec Holdings purchased the 50-square-mile property in 2022 and signed offers to pipe nearly 18 million gallons per day to the Metropolis of Tyler.

“There’s constantly people out there trying to lease water rights to see if they could do a project to sell water,” stated Gary Westbrook, common supervisor of the Publish Oak Savannah Groundwater Conservation District. “We’re going to have to find a way to regulate. You can’t just say no.”

A Gatehouse Pipeline is at the moment underneath development to Georgetown, with one other one referred to as Recharge in growth. Morgan, the Georgetown metropolis supervisor, stated these two tasks have been recognized and accelerated after the lawsuit challenged the Upwell mission.

“We believe the lawsuit is going to likely delay getting that fully resolved,” he stated.

The Upwell mission

Upwell Water, a San Francisco-based financing agency, introduced in 2020 that it had raised $1 billion from traders “to monetize water assets.”

Upwell partnered with CoreCapital traders in Houston, which purchased its 9,000-acre Robertson County farm property in 2021. Lynch, the managing companion at CoreCapital, stated he anticipated to sit down on the property for 10 years till the economics of water made it enticing to develop a serious export mission.

However as quickly as he entered the market, he discovered keen patrons keen to pay nicely.

“We bought it and all of a sudden we had everybody calling saying we need water,” Lynch stated. “Then we said, we have more demand than we can supply, let’s talk to the neighbors.”

Upwell recruited seven neighboring landowners to place firm wells on their property and contribute to the export mission.

These aren’t common irrigation wells, which on this space can faucet water 40 ft down. These are 1,400 ft deep, cased in 2-foot-wide metal pipe, capable of produce massive volumes.

“It’s a million-dollar hole,” stated Mark Hoelscher, one of many neighboring landowners concerned within the mission, as he regarded up at one of many diesel-powered nicely installations. “It’s big time.”

In October 2022, Upwell acquired permits for 16 wells to pump practically 45 million gallons per day with none challenges within the listening to course of. 4 months later it acquired its allow to export the water out-of-district. Then in September 2023, the district issued permits for one more 32 wells belonging to the seven adjoining landowners to supply an extra 45 million gallons per day.

Till that time, authorities within the Bryan-School Station metro space, some 30 miles south, apparently remained unaware of the mission transpiring in Robertson County. Not till September 2024, when the district thought of purposes for up to date permits to export the mixed 89 million-gallon-per-day manufacturing of all 48 wells, did Texas A&M College enter into the proceedings, submitting a request for assessment by the State Workplace of Administrative Hearings.

Texas A&M College declined to remark for this story.

“No one has questioned the fact that we own the land and we have rights to the water underneath it,” stated Hoelscher, a 3rd technology landowner within the Brazos River Valley. “The fact of the matter is the water is ours.”

Texas A&M sues to assessment permits

One week later, A&M filed a lawsuit in state district courtroom in search of a short lived injunction stopping the groundwater district from recognizing any of the permits related to the Upwell mission till a listening to is held.

A&M argued that the beforehand issued permits must be open for re-examination as a result of some board members of the groundwater district have been ineligible for service on the time the permits have been initially authorised.

In November, Bryan and School Station filed papers to affix the lawsuit. It stated their “ability to produce groundwater from their Simsboro wells and the economic vitality of the region will be adversely affected if the Contested Applications are granted.”

School Station Mayor John Nichols, a former professor of agricultural sciences at Texas A&M, stated in a press release: “The transfer of groundwater from our district to users in other areas is one of the most significant issues facing the College Station/Bryan area. I’m a staunch proponent of private property rights, but we are deeply concerned about the long-term impact of excessive extraction on our community.”

He referred to as on lawmakers to undertake statewide groundwater laws making certain the rights of present allow holders over new water customers.

None of that, nevertheless, issues to the trial that can happen in early Might. All of the decide will resolve is whether or not or not A&M and the cities have rights to problem the beforehand issued permits.

In courtroom filings, Upwell argued A&M’s petition “demands that the Court turn back time and recognize a non-existent ‘right’ to administratively contest final groundwater permits that the Brazos Valley Groundwater Conservation District properly noticed and issued to Intervenors months and years prior — all without any complaint or contest by any party, including Plaintiff.”

If the decide denies A&M’s request, the permits shall be issued and work will start on the Upwell mission pipeline.

If the decide grants A&M’s request, the permits will head right into a probably yearslong technique of state administrative hearings that would threaten the viability of the mission and its promised returns to traders.

A race to pump earlier than restrictions kick in

Whether or not or not the pipeline will get constructed, different related tasks are prone to observe. The scenario is headed in a single course: towards the DFC, the brink at which restrictions start.

Within the Brazos Valley and surrounding districts, that threshold is a 262-foot drop in water wells from ranges measured in 2000. Within the 25 years since then, pumping has led the wells’ water to drop by one quarter of that allotted discount, based on district supervisor Day, suggesting ample water provides stay.

However, that continues to be to be seen. In whole, Day stated his district has issued permits for as much as 291 million gallons per day of pumping from the Simsboro Formation, averaged yearly, of which 89 million gallons per day are related to the Upwell mission. Nonetheless, solely a fraction of that permitted quantity is definitely pumped.

If all permitted pumping have been to abruptly come on-line, Day stated, laptop fashions confirmed they might hit the DFC in six years.

In actuality it received’t occur fairly that quick. The Upwell mission plans to scale up its pumping step by step over years. And lots of farmers maintain irrigation permits to pump far more water than they ever truly will, until in addition they encounter the chance to affix an export mission.

When the aquifer hits the DFC, the principles say it mustn’t fall additional. Meaning all customers would face obligatory curtailment. It’s unclear how such unprecedented measures could be enforced in Texas.

For Gutierrez, the mayor of Bryan, this administration technique creates a contest for traders to faucet the water-wealthy Simsboro Formation and dump its bounty earlier than time runs out.

“They want to exploit everything we have for their personal benefit,” he stated. “It’s a race of who can take the most amount of water in the least amount of time to deplete a resource for their pocketbooks.”

Disclosure: Amazon Net Providers (AWS), Apple, the Metropolis of Bryan, Google, Texas A&M College and Texas A&M College System have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no position within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full record of them right here.

---

We are able to’t wait to welcome you to the fifteenth annual Texas Tribune Competition, Texas’ breakout concepts and politics occasion taking place Nov. 13–15 in downtown Austin. Step contained in the conversations shaping the way forward for training, the financial system, well being care, vitality, expertise, public security, tradition, the humanities and a lot extra.

Hear from our CEO, Sonal Shah, on TribFest 2025.

TribFest 2025 is introduced by JPMorganChase.