Join The Transient, The Texas Tribune’s each day e-newsletter that retains readers in control on probably the most important Texas information.
On a Friday evening in late October, a imaginative and prescient in a black pantsuit walked onstage in downtown Houston and bestowed her help upon Vice President Kamala Harris. Beyoncé didn’t endorse Harris as a musician, an influencer, a Democrat and even Texas’ most well-known daughter.
She endorsed as a mom — “a mother who cares deeply about the world my children and all of our children live in,” she stated. “A world where we have the freedom to control our bodies.”
This rally, through which Texas OB/GYNs and girls denied medically needed abortions shared the identical stage as Beyoncé and Willie Nelson, was the climax of a nationwide presidential marketing campaign targeted on abortion entry, girls’s well being and reproductive alternative after the overturn of Roe v. Wade in 2022. Texas, the place abortion has been restricted longer than some other state, was “ground zero” for this challenge, Harris stated to a crowd of 20,000 screaming followers.
Ten days later, Republicans routed Democrats in Texas and throughout the nation. President Donald Trump simply received the state by 14 factors, growing his help throughout nearly all demographic teams, together with girls, exit polls point out. Sen. Ted Cruz defeated Colin Allred by 9 factors. Down poll, Republicans swept the Texas Supreme Court docket races that Democrats tried to border because the state’s finest shot at an abortion referendum.
It was a devastating loss for Democrats who’d believed this was the “Roevember” the place they’d see a wave of voter registration, elevated turnout and silent defections from girls who beforehand supported Trump. Greater than 70% of Texans need extra exceptions within the state’s abortion legal guidelines, together with for rape, incest and delivery defects, polls present.
However wishing the legal guidelines have been totally different doesn’t imply individuals will routinely vote for the celebration they see as much less liable for creating them, stated Jim Henson, the director of the Texas Politics Venture on the College of Texas at Austin.
“There was just no indication that abortion was going to be the motivating issue that Democrats thought it was going to be,” he stated. “I think that the big question to ask is why, based on the available data, did the campaigns assume something would happen that would make all that data wrong.”
Dwelling economics
In Texas, girls cut up nearly precisely down the center for Trump and Harris, exit polling reveals, a slight shift rightward from earlier presidential elections. Whereas this broadly displays the Republican victory throughout many demographic teams, it additionally reveals Democrats did not mobilize unbiased and undecided voters they hoped can be outraged by the abortion bans, Henson stated.
Crucial Texas information,
despatched weekday mornings.
Texas voters could disagree with the abortion legal guidelines, however they proceed to prioritize financial points, polling has proven constantly over the previous few years. Only a month earlier than the election, each women and men stated their biggest concern was the economic system, adopted by immigration and inflation. Solely about 10% of girls stated abortion was an important challenge, together with 2% of males.
It’s uncommon for a “social issue” to win out over an financial one, stated Laura Merrifield Wilson, a political science professor on the College of Indianapolis who research gender points in politics.
“When things are going well, then people are concerned about social issues and reproductive health and questions of bodily autonomy and government regulation,” she stated. “When people feel like the price of eggs has gotten too expensive and they’re unsure about the future of gas costs, then they care less about some of those other social issues.”
Republicans ran arduous on the economic system, tying Harris to Biden’s low approval numbers and stoking fears of a recession. Democrats, in the meantime, failed to totally join Trump to the state’s new abortion legal guidelines. Whereas Trump has bragged about appointing the three Supreme Court docket justices who dominated with the bulk to overturn Roe v. Wade and permit states to set their very own abortion legal guidelines, he muddied the waters by additionally saying he wouldn’t signal a nationwide abortion ban.
“Trump and Cruz and all of them ran a campaign on, ‘we’re not going to do anything, so don’t worry about it,’” Zeigler stated.
That left Democrats liable for messaging what they feared Republicans would do to additional restrict abortion, in addition to what they themselves have been promising to do to broaden entry. Neither is a straightforward path, requiring Democrats to clarify difficult authorized theories just like the Emergency Medical Remedy and Energetic Labor Act and the Comstock Act, a long-dormant 1800s legislation that prohibits mailing abortion-related objects.
Many citizens could have thought, “I don’t think the federal government can do anything about abortion, and I do think the federal government can do something about inflation,” Zeigler stated.
“It’s not picking between two things I really care about, it’s picking between something that isn’t going to matter and something that is.”
This was evidenced in states like Arizona, Missouri and Montana, the place voters overwhelmingly supported poll measures to guard abortion entry, whereas additionally voting for Trump and Republicans down poll. In Amarillo, voters soundly rejected an anti-abortion “travel ban,” even because the counties town sits in voted overwhelmingly for Trump.
“Voters are saying they support abortion rights, but they’re just not worried about Trump and Republicans in Congress,” Zeigler stated. “Essentially, ‘I can have my abortion rights position, and I can have Republicans, too,’ and I don’t think Harris or Biden did a particularly good job explaining why that might not be true.”
In August, Amanda Zurawski, a Texas lady who nearly died from an an infection after docs delayed treating her being pregnant loss, spoke from the stage on the Democratic Nationwide Conference concerning the influence of Texas’ abortion legal guidelines. Texas girls put ahead their related tales in adverts and marketing campaign stops for Democratic candidates.
Regardless of these devastating tales, it’s nonetheless arduous to make voters perceive that that is one thing that may occur to them, stated Wendy Davis, a former state senator and gubernatorial candidate who now works with Deliberate Parenthood Texas Votes.
“Especially for a lot of low-information voters, what they were feeling in their day-to-day lives, their kitchen table, pocketbook issues is what really resonated with them,” she stated. “But I don’t think it’s a correct narrative to say that it was a mistake for Democrats to run on that issue. I think that we should have had a situation of both/and.”
Henson stated there could have been a option to body abortion as an financial challenge, targeted on girls’s involvement within the workforce. However based mostly on Biden’s approval rankings and other people’s evaluation of the economic system, making an attempt to barely refocus the framing of the abortion challenge is like “moving the deck chairs to get a better view of the iceberg,” he stated.
The state and nationwide Republican sweep means Texas’ abortion legal guidelines, at the very least, should not going wherever anytime quickly. The state doesn’t have a mechanism that permits residents to instantly put a poll measure earlier than voters, that means except the make-up of the Texas Legislature adjustments, the legal guidelines will stay in place as-is.
Come 2026, Democrats will seemingly have extra tales of delayed or denied medical care to inform from Texas, and could possibly level extra clearly to the risk Trump poses on the problem, Zeigler stated.
How both celebration messages on abortion going ahead will rely lots on what Trump does within the subsequent two years, in addition to what occurs on the myriad different points voters say encourage them.
“I think the danger for Republicans is that they interpret this as a mandate to take stringent positions on abortion when the election wasn’t really about abortion for most voters,” Zeigler stated. “And for Democrats, that they interpret it as a sign that they shouldn’t talk about abortion, which is one of their stronger issues, because it wasn’t enough to overcome their weaker issues.”
Disclosure: Deliberate Parenthood and College of Texas at Austin have been monetary supporters of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan information group that’s funded partially by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Monetary supporters play no function within the Tribune’s journalism. Discover a full listing of them right here.
